The Sheep and the Goats

"The Sheep and the Goats" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook. It is given by John Marston, starts near the auction yard in Valentine and ends in the Heartlands. It becomes available once The Spines of America, Pouring Forth Oil IV (one in-game hour later), A Fisher of Men, We Loved Once and True II and Money Lending and Other Sins III are complete. This guide lists it twenty-second of the chapter's 24 missions, which can be played in a different order.

Arthur Morgan and John scatter the hands driving a flock from Emerald Ranch and sell the sheep at the Valentine auction yard. At Keane's Saloon, Leviticus Cornwall arrives with armed guards, who take John and Leopold Strauss hostage to draw out Dutch van der Linde. The gunfight that follows forces the gang to leave Horseshoe Overlook.

Starting pointMission marker: John
Map of the area around Valentine, with the mission's starting point marked Valentine
Location
Starts near the auction yard in the south of Valentine, New Hanover; the flock is taken in the hills outside town; the mission ends in the Heartlands after the escape from Valentine
Rewards
A Rolling Block Rifle, taken from the Valentine gunsmith without paying; the rifle is also sold at gunsmiths from then on
Unlocks
One of the missions required for A Strange Kindness

Started by

The sheep job is John's plan; Dutch waits for them at Keane's Saloon.

Characters

Story

John's lead

Arthur meets John in the south of Valentine. Arthur: "So... feeling better? How's the scar?" John: "I heal pretty fast." Asked whether he has any leads, John points at some sheep: "Got something. You see them?" Arthur: "What, you see yourself as a shepherd now?" John: "Maybe... Come on."

On the way through town, John says the train job was a start, but they need more money until they can get back to Blackwater and collect. Arthur warns him that trying to collect that money any time soon would mean a noose, whatever Dutch says: "Dutch says a lot. Now, that's his gift... saying things." He adds: "I was the prize pony once, now I'm the workhorse." The Pinkertons have already been seen here, a new century is coming, and he reckons that men living their way are "the last".

The gunsmith

John has Arthur tie his horse to a hitching post and sends him into the gun store for a sniper rifle. Arthur asks the gunsmith for a rifle "with a sight on it" and looks through the catalogue. Arthur takes a Rolling Block Rifle and leaves without paying.

The two-storey wooden front of the R.L. Dalton gunsmith on a muddy street in Valentine, passers-by on the boardwalk
The gunsmith in Valentine, where Arthur gets the rifle.

On the way out of town, Arthur asks why John could not buy the gun himself. John had a run-in with the gunsmith earlier and they are not on the best of terms. Arthur: "You had a run-in? I've had a run-in with half that town."

Two people at once

When Arthur calls him cagey, John answers: "I ain't the one taking Jack on fishing trips." Arthur replies that if John says the boy is not his, it makes no difference, and that he will probably only run off again. John asks why Arthur is so interested in his life. Arthur: "Just do one thing or another, not be two people at once, that's all I'm saying."

John: "It ain't that simple. You know that as well as anyone. Same as with you and that girl, what was her name... Mary?" Arthur: "That was different." John: "No, it ain't, just the same."

The flock from Emerald Ranch

John finally explains the plan: a herd of sheep is coming down to auction from Emerald Ranch, whose owner, folk in town say, is trying to stamp out every farm from here to Annesburg. The herd will reach the auction, but a couple of new ranch hands will collect on the sale. They climb to a ridge to get a view, staying at a distance until they know what they are dealing with.

From the clifftop, John tells Arthur to put a shot in near the ranch hands: "They're only ranch hands. Just watch the sheep." One of them does not scare easily, so Arthur fires again, and they flee. The two men ride down to round up the scattered sheep. Arthur asks whether John ever worked on a ranch. John: "No. You?" Arthur: "Oh, a day here or there, but not much."

Once the flock is gathered, Arthur takes over: John should ride on the flank and watch for trouble. John protests that he brought Arthur in on this. Arthur: "It'll be quicker this way, trust me." John gives in and points out the quickest route back to Valentine, round the mountain, and Arthur drives the sheep into town.

The auctioneer

At the auction yard, the auctioneer, Morris Peyton, has the pen closed. He has "seen ones with less... ambiguity about their provenance": for a twenty-five percent kickback, he will not say anything to anybody. Arthur: "Do you want me to put another hole in your head?" The auctioneer: "Folks swing for rustling livestock. Twenty five percent."

John offers fifteen, the auctioneer asks twenty, and John settles on eighteen. The auctioneer agrees: "Done. Calm yourself, friend. Just think of it as... I'm buying your sins." Arthur: "You're buying, but we're paying." They are to come back after the auction for their money, and John says Dutch is waiting for them at the saloon.

Morris Peyton, in a blue striped jacket and a red neckerchief, reading a notebook at a wooden fence, two men leaning on the rails of a pen full of sheep
The auctioneer, Morris Peyton, after the deal with Arthur and John.

On the way, Arthur grumbles: "Eighteen percent? I thought we was doing the robbing here." John: "Still good money." Arthur sarcastically thanks him for all the help: "Can't herd, can't swim..." John: "Give it a rest, will you? We ain't kids no more." Arthur: "We never really was."

Keane's Saloon

At Keane's Saloon, Dutch is arguing with Strauss. Strauss: "Not everything... but, in the end, I don't believe in absolutes, just shades of gray. Compromises." Dutch: "Compromising? Well I have never been a man for compromise, and I fear at my age I am too old to change." Arthur tells Dutch they are waiting to get paid on a few sheep. Dutch sends Strauss and John to make sure there is no funny business, and offers Arthur a drink.

Dutch: "Nothing like talking to old Strauss to make you... want to blow your own brains out. I should have left him where I found him all those years ago. Bookish little Austrian fresh off the boat, his eyes out on stalks." Arthur: "Well, I guess the... Dutch van der Linde finishing school has some strange graduates." Dutch: "That it does. To your good health."

Leviticus Cornwall

A voice calls Dutch out from the street. It is Cornwall, whose train the gang robbed in Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?: "Van der Linde! You don't know me... but you keep robbing me. My name is Leviticus Cornwall. I am not a man to be messed with by the likes of you. Get out here, before I have these men killed!" His guards hold John and Strauss at gunpoint outside the saloon. Cornwall leaves before Dutch and Arthur step outside.

Dutch asks Arthur what he thinks. Arthur: "You start spinning a yarn and... when I think the moment's right... I'll make a move." Dutch: "Why not." He walks out and addresses the guards: "Please, gentlemen, this is a terrible mistake. This is a case... of mistaken identity. What is worse... than admonishing a man... for the sins... of another? Who wants to be the Messiah? Not me... Nor do I want to be this 'Dutch van der Linde,' whomever he may be. I am Archibald Smith." While he talks, Arthur draws and shoots the men holding John and Strauss.

The gunfight in Valentine

A gunfight breaks out in the town. Dutch: "Let's move up! Let's go, come on!" Strauss: "Where are you going? That's right at them!" Dutch: "We don't run, Mr. Strauss!" As they push down the main street, Strauss is shot. John: "Strauss is down!" Dutch tells Arthur to cover them while he and John push a wagon forward as cover.

Leopold Strauss, in a grey tweed jacket and dark trousers, sitting in the back of a wooden wagon with one hand on his leg
Strauss, wounded, during the gunfight in Valentine.

John: "It's just a scratch, shut up!" Arthur: "You can talk. We all heard you whine about a little knick from a wolf." Dutch: "Would you shut up and kill these bastards?" When Strauss cries that this is madness, Dutch answers: "You're on the front line now, Mr. Strauss!" Strauss: "I can't do this!" John: "Least you ain't pushing this thing!"

Leaving Valentine

Dutch spots their horses: "Let's get Strauss and go." Strauss calls for help. Dutch: "Arthur we leave no man behind. Go get Strauss." Arthur: "Come on, Leopold. You're fine." Strauss: "I'm not fine." Arthur carries him to John's horse and puts him on the back of it.

Dutch tells Arthur to make sure nobody follows them: "We'll get back to camp... We're gonna gather the troops... and get 'em to start packing up." Arthur: "So... we can't stick around after this." Dutch, John and Strauss ride off. Arthur stays behind, fights off the lawmen and escapes from Valentine.

Two lawmen crouching behind wooden crates in a grassy yard between the buildings of Valentine
Valentine lawmen during the escape.

Consequences

  • Valentine is closed to the player for a while after the mission.
  • A bounty is applied in New Hanover for the shootout, whatever Arthur's previous status.
  • The gang leaves Horseshoe Overlook: in A Strange Kindness, it moves to Clemens Point, in Lemoyne.

In the newspapers

The Blackwater Ledger (No. 64), the New Hanover Gazette (No. 29) and the Saint Denis Times (No. 45) report the gunfight under the title "A Horror Show", with the deck "Blood in the streets of Valentine. Lawmen, Dutch's gang, Cornwall guard face off. Dead everywhere. Families grieving. Coroner overwhelmed." The article says that agents working for Leviticus Cornwall joined in, "quickly creating a scene of unmitigated chaos", and that local officials are calling on state and federal authorities for help.

Mission failure

The mission fails if the player:

  • assaults, kills or abandons John, Dutch or Strauss, or lets one of them be killed;
  • kills all the sheep;
  • alerts the law;
  • abandons Valentine;
  • kills or abandons his horse;
  • dies.

Deaths

  • Cornwall's guards, killed by Arthur, John and Dutch.
  • Valentine lawmen, who can be killed by Arthur during the escape.
  • The ranch hands, if Arthur shoots them from the cliff instead of scaring them off.
Choices and variants

Paying for the rifle

The rifle is free in every case. If Arthur does not have enough money, he tells the gunsmith he will take it on credit; when the gunsmith objects that they have not discussed terms, Arthur offers to take it "in a way that... ain't so polite", and the gunsmith lets him pay later. The player never has to pay him afterward. If Arthur has robbed the gunsmith before the mission, the conversation is more hostile.

The ranch hands and the sheep

Arthur can ignore John's instructions and kill one of the ranch hands or a sheep with the rifle; John then shows his exasperation. Killing all the sheep fails the mission.

The hostages

  • If Arthur takes too long to shoot the men holding John and Strauss, Dutch loses patience and shouts at him to shoot one of them; John and Strauss are then killed and the mission fails.
  • If Arthur shoots Strauss's captor in the head, the man does not fall, and Strauss still wrestles the gun out of his hand.

Wanted before the mission

If Arthur becomes wanted near the southern entrance of the auction yard before starting the mission, John fights the lawmen for a few moments, then mounts his horse and flees while firing at the deputies. If the player mounts up as well, John follows him; once the law is shaken off, John rides around for a while, then disappears.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Herd all the sheep into the pen in Valentine.
2Get 25 headshots.
3Complete the mission with at least 70% accuracy.
4Complete the mission without taking any health items.

To herd the sheep, tap the sprint button so that the horse gallops just behind the last sheep, and aim at the flock to shout at it rather than firing warning shots. The headshot target is strict: Dead Eye tonics do not count as health items. During the wagon push, staying just in front of the wagon gives more targets than hiding behind it, where Dutch and John take the kills; moving too far ahead fails the mission for abandonment.

Quotes
  • You know that attempt to seem all... enigmatic and interesting... that might work for Dutch, but for you... it just makes you look stupid.
    Arthur, when John will not say where they are going
  • I already don't like how this is going... The gun store?
    Arthur, at the hitching post
  • Most cowboys I know are... dumb as trees. How hard could it be?
    John, about herding the sheep
  • Then that's the way it goes, I guess.
    John, when Arthur says they are the last
  • Calm down... it's done now, ain't it?
    John, when Arthur complains about his run-ins
Trivia
  • The title comes from the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats in the Gospel of Matthew (25:31-46), in which the Son of Man separates the nations as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats.
  • This is Leviticus Cornwall's first appearance in person; in Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?, he is only seen in portraits on his train.
  • The sheep in this mission carry a painted "ER" mark on their flanks, for Emerald Ranch. The mark is not seen outside the mission.
  • In the epilogue, after whichever of Jim Milton Rides, Again? and Fatherhood, For Idiots is completed first, John remembers Arthur's advice about not being two people at once.
  • While the mission has not been played, Strauss and Dutch may come out and fire on anyone attacking Arthur near the mission marker in Valentine, bounty hunters for example.
  • The auctioneer, Morris Peyton, appears again in the 1907 end credits, sitting in Smithfield's Saloon with a woman when Edgar Ross and Archer Fordham approach him.
  • A rare glitch can set Arthur's horse on fire, if it is hitched near a campfire, and kill it during the last part of the gunfight, which forces the player to reload the mission.