An American Pastoral Scene
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 24 of 24
Available after Blessed are the Meek?; can be played in a different order, or in Chapter 3
"An American Pastoral Scene" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook. It is given by Micah Bell, starts at his camp at Monto's Rest, near Strawberry, and takes place in Big Valley, West Elizabeth. It becomes available after Blessed are the Meek?, or after A Strange Kindness if it has not been unlocked before. This guide lists it last of the chapter's 24 missions, which can be played in a different order.
It is the only Chapter 2 mission that can also be played in Chapter 3, up to Advertising, The New American Art. To make up for the jailbreak, Micah takes Arthur Morgan to rob a banking coach bound for Strawberry, a job he heard about from an O'Driscoll while in jail.

- Location
- Starts at Micah's camp at Monto's Rest, near Strawberry; Big Valley, West Elizabeth; ends on the Dakota River
- Rewards
- A Lancaster Repeater, handed over by Micah; the rifle is also sold at gunsmiths from then on; Arthur's share of the lockbox
- Unlocks
- Required for Advertising, The New American Art in Chapter 3
Started by
Micah has been camping near Strawberry since Arthur got him out of jail in Blessed are the Meek?.
Story
Micah's camp
Arthur finds Micah at his camp near Strawberry. Micah says it is good to see him. Arthur: "Why? You want rescuing again, do ya?" Micah laughs and says he has a plan to make it up to him. Arthur asks whether it is a plan like the Blackwater ferry job, or like Micah going off scouting and ending up in jail.
Micah answers: "Dutch said you was a big shadow cast by a tiny tree." Arthur: "I don't even know what that means." Micah says he thought Arthur was a tough boy, not a gentleman protecting his riding clothes. Arthur answers that whenever things get real, Micah turns yellow and loses his head. Micah then mentions the banking coach that comes into Strawberry about this time, which he heard an O'Driscoll talk about while he was inside. Arthur: "You and me? Do a robbery?"
The ride to the ridge
Micah leads the way to a spot with a good view of the trail. Arthur asks why he is camping out like a hermit. Micah says he cannot stay in town now, and that he is not going back to Dutch without a peace offering. Asked about the coach's guards, Micah says it is nothing serious. Arthur has heard that the banks have been hiring every trigger man they can get, and does not trust a tip that an O'Driscoll gave Micah "when you was half-drunk in a jail cell."
Micah says the O'Driscolls have hold of most of Big Valley, and that he has heard they took over a big ranch north of there. When Arthur asks how he and Lenny ended up down here, Micah talks of "a few loose ends, drink here, drink there", and says he always pays his share. Arthur brings up Strawberry, where Micah made him kill half the town for his guns. Micah: "Precious, they are... you need to roll a little looser, Morgan." Arthur says he has seen Micah come undone more than once, and Micah has only been riding with the gang a few months. Micah cuts the argument short, and Arthur agrees: "Guess we're robbing it."
The coach
On the ridge, Micah says the coach should be there in a little while, coming from over there, and that they must hit it fast, before it gets into town. Arthur: "Just don't lose your head this time." The coach appears on time, with mounted guards. The two men ride out to attack it. Micah shouts that this is a robbery, then that they must take out the driver. They kill the guards and the driver.
Micah takes the reins and tells Arthur to get on. He calls his horse, Baylock, to follow. He picks up a new rifle, a Lancaster Repeater, and hands it to Arthur: "That's more your style than mine." Arthur asks whether they should break the box open there and be done with it. Micah answers that it could be more than they can carry, and that a second crew of riders might be tailing the coach.
The O'Driscoll ambush
Near the Dakota River, O'Driscolls cut down a tree across the road in front of the coach. Arthur: "Shit, now we're being robbed! Get across the river!" A stick of dynamite blows up the coach, and both men are thrown into the river. Micah asks Arthur whether he is all right; Arthur thinks so. More O'Driscolls arrive, including a wagon coming down the track. Arthur and Micah kill most of them, and the last ones flee.
The lockbox
Arthur goes to the overturned coach: "Let's see if all this was worth it." At Micah's request, he shoots the lock off the lockbox. Micah asks what the cut is. Arthur: "Just make sure the gang gets its piece." Micah repeats: "Like I said... big shadow, tiny tree." Arthur answers that it still does not mean anything, and tells Micah to go and see Dutch, making sure he is not followed. Micah: "I know, boss. I know. It's been fun!" The two men split the take and ride off separately. The mission ends there.
Mission failure
The mission fails if:
- the player assaults or abandons Micah;
- Micah or the player dies;
- the coach is not stopped before it reaches the bridge;
- the coach is crashed or abandoned before it is blown up;
- the player's horse or Baylock dies.
Deaths
- The coach's guards and driver, killed by Arthur and Micah.
- Several O'Driscolls, killed by Arthur and Micah while trying to take the coach.
Choices and variants
When to play it
The mission can be played in Chapter 2 or in Chapter 3. It must be completed before Advertising, The New American Art, the latest point at which it can be put off. Micah only heads back to Dutch at the end of this mission.
The official guide's flowchart ties its unlock after Blessed are the Meek? to two notes: "After 12 in-game hours" and "If only one mission open".
The lockbox
If the player does not shoot the lock, Micah grows impatient and does it himself.
Gold Medal objectives
| # | Objective |
|---|---|
| 1 | Headshot each of the mounted guards protecting the wagon. |
| 2 | Get 10 kills in Dead Eye. |
| 3 | Complete within 6 minutes. |
| 4 | Complete the mission without taking any health items. |
This is the only mission in the game where the cutscenes count against the timer: they must be skipped. Dead Eye slows the action but not the timer. If the player waits too long, Micah may kill one of the mounted guards himself, which fails the first objective.
The mission counts toward Gold Rush (70 Gold Medals in story missions) and Best in the West (100% completion).
Quotes
You worry too much.
Micah, when Arthur says the banks have been hiring gunmenDamn O'Driscolls are everywhere now.
Arthur, on the ride to the ridgeSee, I told you this'd be fun, Morgan!
Micah, during the chaseThis is fun for you?
Arthur, in replyWhat did I tell ya? Like licking butter off a knife.
Micah, once the coach is takenAll I see is you, me, a river full of dead O'Driscolls and a lockbox. I'd say we're golden here, Morgan.
Micah, at the overturned coach
Trivia
- Arthur can take a Lancaster Repeater from the guards before Micah hands him one, and so end up with two.
- One of the mounted guards wears a Liberty Hat, which can be missed.
- If the player strays too far from Micah during either shootout, Arthur is killed by a single shot, whatever his health.
- Staying too long by the river after the mission draws the law.
- The Lancaster Repeater sounds different in this mission than in free roam.
- Micah's Revolver can be obtained early here, by leading a disarmed enemy to Micah so that the man knocks the gun from his hand.

