A Strange Kindness

"A Strange Kindness" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 and the last mission of Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook. It is given by Dutch van der Linde, starts at the Horseshoe Overlook camp and takes place at Dewberry Creek, in Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne. It becomes available once Who is Not Without Sin, The Sheep and the Goats and Blessed are the Meek? are complete. This guide lists it 23rd of the chapter's 24 missions.

After the shootout in Valentine, the gang must leave Horseshoe Overlook. Dutch sends Arthur Morgan and Charles Smith to scout Dewberry Creek. They find a German family whose father has been kidnapped, free him, and settle the gang at the spot where he was held: Clemens Point.

Starting pointMission marker: Dutch
Map of the area around Horseshoe Overlook, with the mission's starting point marked Horseshoe Overlook
Location
Starts at the Horseshoe Overlook camp; Dewberry Creek, Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne; ends at Clemens Point, on Flat Iron Lake
Rewards
A gold bar from Andreas; "To Greener Pastures" trophy for completing Chapter 2
Unlocks
Clemens Point as the gang's camp; Chapter 3, with The New South and Further Questions of Female Suffrage; An American Pastoral Scene if it was not unlocked before; the Double-Action Revolver at gunsmiths

Characters

At camp

Andreas's wife, daughter and son, and the men holding him for ransom.

Story

Packing up at Horseshoe Overlook

After The Sheep and the Goats, Arthur rides back to camp. Susan Grimshaw greets him. In Dutch's tent, Hosea is arguing with Dutch about the move. He asks whether the plan is to keep heading east, and when they will stop: "when we reach Paris?" Dutch jokes about joining the Commune, then says they will stop when they find somewhere sensible, shake off the people following them and lie low.

Hosea answers that this is not lying low: they have "turned into a bunch of killers", without even the delusion of being anything else. Dutch says they are only trying to survive and have no choice, and that it will end soon. Hosea: "Damn right it will." Dutch comments: "Constipated as usual."

Dutch tells Arthur that Micah told him of a place where they can lie low, Dewberry Creek, and asks him to go and look at it with Charles and clear off anyone they find before the whole gang moves in. Asked how, Dutch answers: "Start dancing?" Arthur says: "Looks like I've turned into the goddamn errand boy." Dutch replies: "You have turned into my son... you worry, because I worry. We are just the same."

The ride south

Arthur calls Charles, and they ride out. Arthur explains that the gang is moving again, and fast: they had already pushed their luck before the mess in Valentine, where they "killed a lot of law" and a lot of Cornwall's men. Charles has only known Dutch a few months, but from the way he talks, he never thought he would see him heading south. Arthur says there is no lying low for the gang; Charles adds that there are too many of them for that.

Arthur adds that Dutch would never hide away in a cave somewhere: it goes against everything he stands for, and it would mean admitting they are nothing more than low-down criminals. Charles: "Which... we are." Charles then asks where the moving and running end. Arthur says Dutch does not see it as running, and that in the past, enough time and distance between you and the problem made it go away.

Dewberry Creek

Dewberry Creek is an old dried-up creek. Charles finds it very open, and Arthur doubts it would be any good in the rain. Charles spots a body on the ground. Arthur: "He's been shot. Looks like trouble got here before us." Charles sees a camp just ahead. Arthur tells him to shoot first and debate second; Charles answers that he is not going to shoot for the sake of it.

The camp has a few tents and looks empty. Under a wagon, they find a woman hiding with two children, the woman holding a shotgun. Charles tells her they mean no harm. She asks whether they speak German. Arthur tells the family to leave: "Go, we need the land." The daughter then says: "They took our father." Men took him the night before. Arthur says it is none of their business and that he does not even speak their language. Charles: "You ain't as tough and dense as all that. Come on, Arthur."

A woman in a blue dress and red neckerchief aims a double-barreled shotgun from under a wagon, between a boy in a cap and a girl
Hiding under their wagon, the mother points a shotgun at Arthur and Charles.

On the kidnappers' trail

The girl pointed the way, and Charles picks up hoof marks. He asks Arthur whether he was really going to send the woman and her children on their way. Arthur answers that they are wanted men with Pinkertons on their heels, and should be moving camp, "not running off on some wild goose chase." Charles: "That's not how you are." Arthur: "Well, maybe you don't know me as well as you think you do."

On the trail, Charles asks what happened with the Pinkertons when Arthur was fishing with Jack, in A Fisher of Men. Arthur says they told him they were onto the gang and offered him freedom if he turned Dutch in. He thinks the gang should have moved right then. He adds that they told him they had killed Mac, right in front of Jack. Charles says it will be tough for the boy; Arthur answers that Jack has more people looking out for him than most of them had growing up.

Charles mentions that John was going back to the auction yard to collect the money for the sheep. Arthur says he would be an idiot to go near the town now, then adds: "Oh, well... if it's John's idea, it must be a good one." Charles asks what is between the two of them. Arthur says John disappeared on them for a year or more when Jack was very young: "Guess I still ain't fully forgiven him for that."

The camp by Flat Iron Lake

The trail leads to a clearing on the shore of Flat Iron Lake, with a camp that seems deserted. Charles notes that it is a better camp spot than the creek, and much easier to defend. Arthur finds the father tied up. The man calls for help, then warns them in German that it is a trap. Three men come at them. Arthur: "Why the hell you drag us into this, Charles?" Then riders arrive.

Once the attackers are dead, Charles goes to see what they left behind while Arthur cuts the man, Andreas, free. Arthur decides the spot will work for the gang and sends Charles to find Dutch and divert the caravan there. He then takes the man back to his family.

A gold bar

On the ride, Arthur asks why the men took him. The settler answers: "Geld. Money." Then, in German, he explains that his family has a gold mining business and that the men wanted a ransom. Arthur asks how anyone even came up with those words, and ends with: "Look I'm sorry, friend, I can barely speak English."

The family is reunited. In German, the wife tells her husband she thought he was dead, then tells Arthur he is a great man. Arthur tells them the place is not safe and that they must leave, adding "Vamos!" Before going, Andreas gives him a gold bar and thanks him, once in English. Arthur: "Guess it was a pleasure."

A woman in a blue dress, a blonde girl with braids, a man in a blue suit and a small boy in a cap, standing by a wooden wagon
Andreas, back with his family.

Clemens Point

Some time later, Dutch and the rest of the gang arrive at the lakeside clearing. Dutch: "Oh, this place... it'll be perfect for us." He tells Miss Grimshaw and Mr. Pearson to put everyone to work and make the place a home, and adds: "Well, I don't know where the hell we are... but, we are going to make the best of it." The mission ends there, and with it Chapter 2.

Tents and tarps under a large tree in a grassy clearing, with a few people and horses in the haze
The gang's camp at Clemens Point.

Chapter 3 is named after the new camp, Clemens Point, near the town of Rhodes. Its first missions, The New South and Further Questions of Female Suffrage, open after this mission.

Mission failure

The mission fails if the player:

  • assaults, kills or abandons Charles, or lets him be killed;
  • assaults or kills the family (aiming a weapon at the woman makes her open fire);
  • assaults, kills or abandons the hostage;
  • kills or abandons his horse;
  • dies.

Deaths

  • The man in the creek bed, shot shortly before the mission.
  • The kidnappers, killed by Arthur and Charles.
Choices and variants

Tracking with Eagle Eye

While Charles follows the trail, the player can track Andreas with Eagle Eye. If Arthur finds the tracks quickly, he tells Charles which way they go before Charles works it out himself. This also works while Arthur is talking about the gang.

The body in the creek

Even if the player reaches the dead man first, Charles speaks his line as if he had found the body himself.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Return the captive to his family within 1 minute and 40 seconds.
2Get 5 headshots.
3Complete with at least 80% accuracy.
4Complete the mission without taking any health items.

The shootout can start at night, which makes headshots harder: entering Dead Eye only when a target is in view helps. The mission counts toward Gold Rush (70 Gold Medals in story missions) and Best in the West (100% completion).

Quotes
  • So, we moving?
    Arthur, entering Dutch's tent
  • Survival's for the sake of it.
    Arthur, to Charles, before searching the camp at Dewberry Creek
  • They picked the wrong man there.
    Charles, on the Pinkertons' offer to Arthur
  • Ah, that didn't sound good.
    Charles, when Arthur mentions the mess in Valentine
Trivia
  • With low honor, Arthur remembers two lines from this mission later in the game: Hosea's line about the gang turning into killers, in A Fork in the Road, and Dutch's line calling Arthur his son, during his last ride in Red Dead Redemption.
  • Dutch says Micah told him about Dewberry Creek. An American Pastoral Scene, after which Micah heads back to Dutch, is not required for this mission and can be put off until Chapter 3, which can keep Micah away from camp for most of Chapter 2.
  • In Chapter 6, the gang's last camp, Beaver Hollow, is set around a cave.
  • The hammers of the shotgun the woman points at Arthur and Charles are not cocked.
  • After the rescue, Charles rides back to the middle of the Horseshoe Overlook camp and stays on his horse. Although the gang is supposed to be packing up, the camp is unchanged and everyone behaves as usual, except that Arthur's quarters have disappeared.
  • The mission description in the game spells Dewberry as "Dewbury".