The Course of True Love II
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 4 of 18
Continues straight on from The Course of True Love I
"The Course of True Love II" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It continues The Course of True Love I without a break, from Caliga Hall to Braithwaite Manor. This guide lists it fourth of the chapter's 18 missions, which can be played in a different order.
Arthur Morgan slips onto the Braithwaite estate without being seen and gives Beau Gray's letter and bracelet to Penelope Braithwaite. She talks about the two families and gives Arthur a letter of her own for Beau.

- Location
- From Caliga Hall to Braithwaite Manor, the Braithwaite plantation by the water in Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne, outside Rhodes
- Unlocks
- The Course of True Love III; An Honest Mistake, which needs either this mission or American Distillation
Started by
Beau gives Arthur the letter and the bracelet at the end of The Course of True Love I.
Characters
The Braithwaite guards patrol the grounds. Penelope is the niece of Catherine Braithwaite.
Story
Onto the Braithwaite estate
Arthur rides from Caliga Hall to Braithwaite Manor, the plantation of the rival family, on the water in Scarlett Meadows outside Rhodes. The first objective is to sneak into the grounds around the manor.
Braithwaite guards patrol the estate. Arthur has to get past them unseen to reach Penelope, who is sitting in the gazebo on the edge of the property, where Beau said she likes to sit. The game suggests getting off the horse to stay out of sight.
Penelope Braithwaite
Arthur reaches the gazebo. "Are you Penelope Braithwaite?" "Why yes, I am." When he says he has a letter for her (and the bracelet, if he has kept it), she is surprised: "A letter and a gift? Well we don't even know each other." Arthur explains that they are not from him, and she guesses straight away: "From Beau! Oh, he is so..." Arthur finishes the sentence for her: "Strange?"
Penelope agrees, up to a point: "Well, yes, he's a little strange... but also, so human. The rest of our families are stuck in the Dark Ages, or... well, I don't know... cave people, perhaps. Beau's different, but if they find out... they'll kill him, and send me to live someplace awful like... Ohio. Have you ever been to Ohio, sir?" Arthur says no.
Neither has she: "Well, neither have I, but my uncle has a factory there. He was sort of the black sheep, on account of having left... but now they tolerate him, because he's a vicious snob." She asks Arthur whether he has a family. He answers: "No... not really." Penelope adds that her family puts up with the uncle because of his money, but cannot stand her, with her "ideas above my station".
Back out unseen
Penelope answers: "Well nothing to say, except I hope they all rot. I-I don't... well... maybe a bit... but here... if you see Beau again, will you give this to him?" She hands Arthur a letter for Beau, and he agrees. He then has to leave the area without being spotted by the guards.
The next objective is to take Penelope's letter to Beau. The hand-over at Caliga Hall opens The Course of True Love III.
Choices and variants
Without the bracelet
If Arthur has sold Beau's bracelet to a fence before the meeting, Penelope has different lines: she notes that Beau usually sends her a gift along with his letters.
Mission failure
- Alerting the Braithwaite guards, or killing one of them.
- Attacking Beau, the Grays or Penelope.
- Dying.
Gold Medal objectives
| # | Objective |
|---|---|
| 1 | Reach Penelope without getting spotted. |
| 2 | Complete within 3 minutes. |
On leaving Caliga Hall, take the path to the left through the tobacco fields until a burnt-down house appears on the left, then follow that path straight to the open white gate of the Braithwaite estate. Stay on horseback, despite the game's advice to dismount, until clear of the guards' patrol zone, then ride down to the water and swim the horse across to reach Penelope.
The mission counts toward the Gold Rush trophy (70 Gold Medals in story missions).
Quotes
That sounds pretty complicated, I... I don't know quite what to say.
Arthur, after Penelope has talked about her family
Trivia
- Animation files left in the game show that getting caught was originally meant to end with Arthur hogtied and thrown on the floor of the boathouse. This was cut.
- This is Penelope's first appearance; in The Course of True Love I, she is only talked about.
- Penelope Braithwaite is played by Alison Barton, according to the game's credits.
- Braithwaite Manor is the setting of later Chapter 3 missions, among them Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern, in which the gang storms the house.
