Preaching Forgiveness as He Went

Red Dead Redemption 2

Mission 9 of 18

Started by Lenny

Clemens Point, Lemoyne

Available after An Honest Mistake and two of The Course of True Love III, American Distillation and An American Pastoral Scene; can be played in a different order

"Preaching Forgiveness as He Went" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2, in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is given by Lenny Summers at the Clemens Point camp and takes place at Shady Belle, an old plantation house in the Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne. It becomes available after An Honest Mistake, once two of The Course of True Love III, American Distillation and An American Pastoral Scene are complete. This guide lists it 9th of the chapter's 18 missions; the chapter can be played in a different order.

Lenny has heard in Rhodes that a gang of men who think the Civil War never ended deals in weapons from a manor in the swamps. He and Arthur Morgan follow a wagon of explosives to Shady Belle, wipe out the Lemoyne Raiders guarding it and drive a cart of new rifles back to camp.

Starting pointMission marker: Lenny
Map of the area around Clemens Point, with the mission's starting point marked Clemens Point
Location
Starts and ends at the Clemens Point camp; Bolger Glade, Scarlett Meadows; Shady Belle, Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne
Unlocks
The Bolt Action Rifle: Arthur keeps one from the stolen stash, and it goes on sale at gunsmiths; Sodom? Back to Gomorrah, one in-game hour later, once American Distillation is complete; the Abandoned Church journal entry, if Arthur inspects the church

Characters

The Lemoyne Raiders at Shady Belle, the driver of the dynamite wagon and the three Raiders met on the road back.

Story

Lenny's lead

At Clemens Point, Lenny asks Arthur whether he is busy. Arthur says he is only hunting for the "hillbilly gold" that Dutch and Hosea think is out there waiting to be stolen. Lenny has something that could be good: in Rhodes, talking to Black people in town, he heard of a gang holed up in the swamps east of camp whose members think their war never ended. Arthur asks whether he means the Civil War. Lenny says it is still raging in their minds thirty years later.

These men are weapon dealers. Lenny explains that they have been selling weapons to Cuba and South America for years, and that in their dealings they sometimes sit on a good pile of cash. The man he spoke to thinks there might be money lying around and, failing that, a stash of weapons, guarded only by "a bunch of crazies", as Arthur puts it. Arthur agrees that it is worth a look. Lenny adds that the place is called Shady Belle, deep in the woods.

The ride east

On the way, Arthur says he may already have met these men: some of them harassed him and Sadie when they were coming back with supplies. Sadie handled them well, he adds: "She's terrifying." Lenny remarks that there is no shortage of angry idiots in Lemoyne.

Arthur asks whether the state is really that different, since they have not come far, and says he has not noticed much. Lenny answers that with respect, Arthur would not notice. Men here might call Arthur a racial slur for riding with him. Most of it, Lenny says, is a glance or a word, and after that "a visit in the night." Out West, he adds, the gang are decent folks, but some places down here judge differently.

Arthur says he is sorry Lenny is caught up in this. Lenny answers that these men's gold is still shiny and their guns still shoot, so he is game for robbing every one of them, and that it beats being lynched back in Blackwater, with all of the gang by his side.

Bolger Glade

The men in Rhodes told Lenny to find the old battlefield and keep going. At Bolger Glade, Arthur sees the wrecked Civil War weaponry and asks where the Civil War hold-outs are. Lenny points to a church ahead: the Raiders are said to use it as an outpost, with men going back and forth to the big house all day. Arthur suggests they look around first.

Old wooden trenches and earthworks across a field of red earth and grass, with dead trees under a blue sky
The old Civil War battlefield at Bolger Glade.

Lenny hears someone on the track: a wagon. Arthur decides to follow it at a distance, "just two fellers out on the road". On the way, Lenny wonders whether the crates in the back are explosives. They must not lose sight of the wagon, and they must not be spotted.

Shady Belle

At the end of a tree-lined avenue, Lenny spots the big plantation house: Shady Belle. They leave their horses in the trees, off the trail, and take position behind a wall. Lenny asks Arthur to bring his scoped rifle and takes the other side.

A dirt track running between large oak trees towards the dark columned front of a plantation house, under a cloudy sky
The grounds of Shady Belle, in the Bayou Nwa.

Through the scope, Arthur sees that the Raiders are there and armed, "almost a militia", and recognizes dynamite crates. He then gives Lenny two options: hit them head on, or have Lenny walk down acting friendly to draw them into one spot before Arthur opens fire. Lenny calls the second idea maybe the dumbest he has ever heard, but says he is always up for a performance.

Either way, a large firefight breaks out. In the head-on attack, Arthur shouts to the Raiders that he and Lenny are there for their guns and their money. Lenny warns him that a man on the veranda is going for the Gatling gun. When the shooting stops, Lenny says that any men in the area will have heard it and that they should grab something and leave.

Searching the area, Arthur finds a cart "full of new rifles". Lenny asks whether they can sell them; Arthur says they can, and that they will check the rest later. They drive the cart away.

A weathered two-story plantation house with columns and green shutters, overgrown with vines, behind a stone fountain, with a wagon parked to the right
The front of the Shady Belle manor.

The road back

Soon after they leave the woods, riders come their way. One of them asks: "What's a black feller doing coming out of Shady Belle? In one of our wagons?" Arthur and Lenny shoot the three Raiders. Arthur then calls out "Leonard, Leonard, Leonard"; Lenny answers that he is looking, and sees no one following them.

Lenny says he knows Sean has been bringing in a lot lately, and that it is good to have something like this to show. Arthur calls Sean a loudmouth braggart and tells Lenny not to worry about what Sean does. Lenny says he likes Sean; Arthur admits he does too, against his better judgment, and tells Lenny to worry about himself.

Arthur then tells him: "Me and Dutch, and everyone who counts, we know what you do for this gang. We notice. Keep it up, you're going to start seeing things change for you." Lenny thanks him.

Back at Clemens Point, Arthur says the rifles are fine ones and that he will keep one for himself. He tells Lenny he always enjoys riding with him, because he knows how to fight. Lenny: "Hey, you too. Anytime, Arthur." The mission ends there.

Mission failure

The mission fails if the player:

  • assaults, kills or abandons Lenny, or lets him be killed;
  • loses sight of the dynamite wagon, or is spotted while following it;
  • destroys or disables the weapon wagon;
  • kills or abandons his horse;
  • dies.

Deaths

  • Numerous Lemoyne Raiders, killed by Arthur and Lenny at Shady Belle and on the road.
Choices and variants

Head on, or Lenny's performance

After the scope survey, the player chooses how to start the fight. Attacking head on, Arthur tells Lenny: "We're gonna hit 'em head on. You save your play acting for Hosea and the girls." Lenny: "Fine by me." The other option sends Lenny down to the Raiders, acting friendly, to gather them in one place before Arthur opens fire. Shooting a large box of dynamite in the hideout also kills some of the Raiders at once. Either way, the same firefight follows.

Avoiding the last Raiders

If the player leaves the track on the way back to avoid the three Raiders, Lenny remarks that they should have met someone by now.

If Arthur already knows Shady Belle

Shady Belle is a gang hideout that the player can visit from Chapter 2 until this mission starts. If Arthur has been there, he tells Lenny so when they arrive.

The Abandoned Church

The church Lenny points out is the Abandoned Church, a point of interest. If Arthur inspects it and writes about it in his journal during the mission, the entry is available after the mission.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Kill 10 Lemoyne Raiders with a long scoped rifle.
2Complete within 11 minutes and 30 seconds.
3Complete with at least 70% accuracy.
4Complete the mission without taking any health items.
Quotes
  • Let's take it slow. Be cautious... If, like you say, these are crazies sitting on weapons, we're going to want to strategize a little, before getting shot at.
    Arthur, to Lenny, on the ride, before Bolger Glade
  • Silly men playing dress up...
    Arthur, during the firefight at Shady Belle
  • I should think we're out of the woods then, so to speak.
    Arthur, after the three Raiders
  • Well, let's get to camp before saying anything like that.
    Arthur, when Lenny says "We did it"
Trivia
  • The title refers to Luke 3:3, in which John the Baptist goes into all the country around the Jordan, "preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins".
  • This is the only mission in which Arthur calls Lenny by his full name, Leonard.
  • After the mission, the Lemoyne Raiders stop respawning at Shady Belle; the manor cannot be cleared for loot again until after Fleeting Joy. In Chapter 4, Shady Belle becomes the gang's camp.
  • If the player acts quickly after the mission, Arthur can ride Lenny's horse, Maggie, one of the few gang horses the player can ride. She bucks Arthur off and runs back if he tries to leave camp.
  • On the ride to Valentine in Sodom? Back to Gomorrah, Arthur can talk with Lenny about the Shady Belle gang.
  • In a list of ten "respectful representations of blackness in gaming" published by Game Informer on 18 February 2019, Jason Guisao found this mission particularly striking for the way Lenny tells Arthur what it is to be Black in a hateful America.