The New South
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 1 of 18
Available from the start of Chapter 3
"The New South" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 and one of the two missions that open Chapter 3: Clemens Point, the other being Further Questions of Female Suffrage. It is given by Dutch van der Linde and starts at the gang's new camp on Flat Iron Lake, after A Strange Kindness. This guide lists it first of the chapter's 18 missions; the chapter can be played in a different order.
Dutch, Hosea and Arthur ride out to go fishing. On the way they meet Sheriff Leigh Gray of Rhodes and his deputy, Archibald MacGregor, who are taking prisoners to town, Josiah Trelawny among them. The Anderson boys break out, Arthur catches their leader on a moving train, and Trelawny walks free. Arthur can then go fishing with Dutch and Hosea.

- Location
- Starts at the Clemens Point camp; a railroad crossing, the train chase, then Rhodes and the Scarlett Meadows Sheriff's Office; optional fishing on Flat Iron Lake, back to camp by boat
- Rewards
- Honor, if Arthur goes fishing with Dutch and Hosea; the fish caught on the lake
- Unlocks
- The Course of True Love I; American Distillation, three in-game hours later; An Honest Mistake, once The Course of True Love II or American Distillation is complete; the Stranger missions He's British, of Course (unavailable for four in-game hours after American Distillation) and Money Lending and Other Sins IV (unavailable after A Short Walk in a Pretty Town; it leads to the loansharking jobs for Gwyn Hughes and Winton Holmes); the home robbery with Sean and fishing with Kieran and Javier; the Legendary Fish
Story
Dutch by the lake
A few days after the move, Arthur finds Dutch on the shore at Clemens Point, looking out over the water. Dutch remarks that it is funny to end up in the South: "My daddy died in a field in Pennsylvania, fighting this lot. I ever tell you that?" Arthur: "Many times..." Dutch says he sees he is boring him; Arthur answers that he is worried, because they lost men back in Blackwater.
Dutch answers that they have lofty goals, trying to reform society "to a kinder, truer, better way", and that there are bound to be casualties. Arthur: "We're thieves... in a world that don't want us no more." Dutch grants that they are "dreamers in an ever duller world of facts", then changes the subject: the day is nice.
They walk to Hosea by the horses. Dutch says Hosea has told him of a creek nearby, which he reckons is full of fish. He tells Hosea he does not look too well; Hosea: "My days of looking good are long over, Dutch." Dutch calls him a dream crusher and a bubble burster, and the three men ride out.
The old guard
Arthur asks why they do not just fish at camp, on a whole lake. Dutch says he needs to get out for a bit with "the old guard": before everyone back at camp, there was the three of them. Hosea: "The curious couple and their unruly son." Dutch thanks Arthur for finding the spot; Arthur says it was more Charles than him. Hosea remembers being in this country once with Bessie, a lifetime ago.
Dutch sets out the plan: when things are desperate, they stick with it, make enough money, then find somewhere nobody will find them, where they do not have to hide. Hosea asks where; Dutch has "some ideas hatching" and needs both men with him, not against him. Until then, everyone keeps a low profile, especially in the local town, after Valentine, while turning over "the soil and the rocks" to see what turns up. Hosea warns: "Dutch... we have gotta be discreet." Then Dutch sees lawmen ahead and tells the others to play it cool.
The prison wagon
A stopped train blocks the road at a railroad crossing, and a prison wagon is waiting there too. Trelawny is in the cage at the back, with several other prisoners. Dutch: "Well, look what the cat drug in." Trelawny: "I seem to have gotten myself in a spot of bother." A lawman tells him to keep quiet.
Dutch rides up to the two men on the driving seat and introduces himself as Hoagy Macintosh. They are the sheriff, Leigh Gray, and his deputy, Archibald MacGregor. Dutch asks what the "silly fancy fop" in the back has done. The sheriff says he was accused of running a gold mining investment scam. Dutch answers that Trelawny is a magician he knows, a fool but not a bad fellow.
While Dutch talks, one of the prisoners picks the lock. The cage opens and the prisoners run for the departing train. The sheriff: "Shit! The Anderson boys. I can't have more scandal." Dutch offers to help and sends Arthur after them. Arthur: "Chase wanted men?" Dutch tells him to take Archibald along, and Arthur answers: "Just what I signed up for... come on, big guy." As they leave, Dutch turns back to the sheriff: "Perhaps we can discuss the foolish magician?"
The train chase
Archibald climbs onto Arthur's horse and tells him not to shoot: the Anderson boys must be taken alive. He asks Arthur's name; Arthur gives it as Callahan. Archibald: "Faster, Mr. Callahan, please. My neck is on the line here." Arthur asks whether he can shoot the man climbing onto the train. Archibald: "No. Did I not say that?" Arthur: "You've said plenty."
One Anderson boy, standing on the roof of a car, shouts at them and is knocked off the train by a bar over the track. Archibald: "Idiot." The train slows down to go through a station, and Archibald asks Arthur to ride alongside a flatcar and jump on. Arthur: "Me? Why me?" Archibald: "Because you ride like my grandmother."
On the flatcar, an Anderson boy chokes Arthur at the edge of the train before Arthur throws him off: "Damn fool!" Arthur runs along the roofs after the others, knocking them down one by one. The last one, Anders Anderson, is trapped in a closed car. Anders: "I guess it's just us then, lawman. Come here." Arthur: "Do we need to bother?" Anders asks to be let go; Arthur: "I can't do that." Anders comes at him with a knife, and Arthur beats him unconscious with his fists.
The train stops. Archibald asks whether everything is all right inside. Arthur: "Well... I don't think he's dead... but I think I won the fight... just about." Archibald identifies the prisoner as Anders Anderson, congratulates Arthur and gives himself "a pat on the back" for stopping the train. Arthur loads Anders onto the back of his horse.
The road to Rhodes
Archibald says they will round up the others: Anders is the brains of the operation, "and that's really saying something". He guesses that Arthur has served the law himself at some point; Arthur says he would not exactly say that. On the way, Archibald points out the tobacco fields of Caliga Hall, the estate of the Gray family. Arthur finds them bone dry, and Archibald agrees that the area needs rain.
Archibald explains that the Grays have lived at Caliga Hall for generations, that his own family has worked for them for years, and that Sheriff Gray is the one he knows best. The Grays also own businesses in Rhodes, the town where they are heading. He then mentions the Braithwaites, another big family with an estate west of there: "Awful people, truly awful." The two families have been fighting for as long as he can remember.
At the entrance to Rhodes, Archibald lists the town's sights: the Rhodes Parlor House, a saloon owned by the Grays, a general store, a gunsmith, a post office and the train station. Arthur: "What more do you need?" Archibald: "Very little." Hosea is waiting outside the sheriff's office with Trelawny, still in the wagon. Arthur carries Anders inside.
Trelawny walks free
The sheriff comes out with Dutch, who says: "I told you Arthur would deliver... man has a passion for justice." Asked about his friend, the sheriff answers: "Your idiot friend is free to go... but no more trouble from you, partner." Trelawny calls it all a big misunderstanding and thanks him from the bottom of his heart; the sheriff will "pretend to appreciate that".
The sheriff welcomes "Mr. Macintosh" to Rhodes on behalf of its "mostly good citizens" and asks him to make his friend behave: the town already has enough trouble from old-timers who have "gone sadly to seed". Dutch promises to keep Trelawny on the straight and narrow, and the sheriff invites them to come back soon. He then turns to a young man waiting on the porch, Beau, and asks whether it is true he was seen talking to "that wretched Penelope Braithwaite", a thread picked up in The Course of True Love I.
Two families and some bounties
Trelawny says he is renting a caravan on the edge of town, behind the church: horrible, but nobody comes looking. The whole town is trapped in "this interminable feud" between the Grays and the Braithwaites. Dutch: "Interesting." Trelawny adds that the two old plantation houses have fallen out over rebel gold and over marriages between cousins. Dutch tells Arthur and Hosea to start poking around.
Trelawny then says he has heard about bounties. Dutch: "There's been a price on my head for thirteen years... it'll take 'em months to find us down here." Trelawny insists that they are good bounties. Asked by Hosea where he heard it, he names men at a camp near the state line: there is talk of it in bars for five hundred miles to the north and west, and talk of "super agents". Dutch would love to meet one and calls it just talk. Trelawny thanks them and leaves.
Dutch splits the work on the two plantation families: Arthur takes the Grays, whose estate he passed earlier with Archibald, and Hosea the Braithwaites. Arthur: "Quite a fishing trip..." Dutch says there is still time. Hosea asks Arthur whether he has had enough of the chase for one day.
Fishing on Flat Iron Lake
If Arthur accepts, Hosea leads the way. The spot is not a creek but another part of Flat Iron Lake, where Hosea has seen big drum and sturgeon and expects rock bass, bluegill, perch and pickerel. Dutch wonders whether Arthur is as good at catching fish as at catching criminals; Arthur says Trelawny owes him for that. Dutch adds that they are now ingratiated with the local law, which made it "a worthwhile diversion all round".
At the spot, they borrow a rowboat from the shore. Arthur rows: "you boys are too old for real labor no more." Hosea: "And you're too dumb for anything else." Out on deeper water, Hosea says they should use a lake lure, which gives a much better chance of hooking something big like a sturgeon. He tells Arthur to keep the lure moving slowly, like a small fish asking to be eaten, and the three men catch fish.
Hosea mentions a man who once saw a monster lake sturgeon, a fifty-pounder, near the mouth of the river just southwest of Saint Denis. Arthur calls it a day. Dutch reckons Pearson will be happy with the haul. Hosea suggests keeping the boat, since camp is not far, and Dutch agrees; the horses will find their way back. Hosea tells Arthur to follow the shore south.
Three mariners
On the way back, Dutch asks Hosea for a song, and the three men sing together. Dutch then says they should be singing a sea song, since they are "three mariners", and they sing one that begins "Well, we be three poor mariners". Dutch adds that they should not let the folks at camp think they had too much fun.
Dutch tells them he always knows that things are going to be fine when he has the two of them by his side: "This place will be good for us. For now, anyway." Hosea: "I hope so." At camp, Dutch goes to take in the view and Hosea takes the fish to Pearson. The mission ends there.
Mission failure
The mission fails if the player:
- assaults, kills or abandons Dutch, Hosea or Archibald MacGregor;
- lets the Anderson boys escape, or kills any of them (Archibald then asks: "What the hell's wrong with you?");
- kills or abandons his horse;
- destroys or abandons the boat, if he goes fishing;
- dies.
Choices and variants
At the prison wagon
At the crossing, the player can greet Trelawny ("Well, well, look who it is...") or say nothing, in which case Dutch says he will sort it out.
Night or day
Dutch's lines at the start depend on the time of day. During the day, he says the day is nice, as above. If the mission starts at night, he says it looks to be a nice day ahead, that Hosea knows a good fishing spot, and that leaving now will catch "the early biters".
Going fishing or not
After Trelawny's release, the player chooses whether Arthur goes fishing. If he declines ("Eh... I'll need to relax someplace."), Dutch and Hosea leave together and the mission ends in Rhodes; Arthur loses no honor. If he accepts, he gains a small amount of honor and the mission ends at Clemens Point, by boat.
Questions on the ride
On the ride to the fishing spot, the player picks one of two subjects, then one of two more.
- The fishing spot. Arthur asks whether it is in Timbuktu. Hosea asks what really happened with Cornwall in Valentine, in The Sheep and the Goats, "apart from scaring the living daylights out of Mr. Strauss". Arthur says he and John never got paid for the sheep, and that Cornwall ambushed them in the saloon with guards and what seemed like every lawman in the county. Hosea adds that the Pinkertons cannot have been far behind; Arthur reminds them that they found him while he was fishing with Jack, in A Fisher of Men. Hosea says Jack told him Arthur was a good teacher, and that he answered the boy must have him confused with someone else.
- Trelawny. Arthur says Trelawny is "like a bad penny". Hosea is not sure how good a magician he is, but he is good at disappearing. Dutch grants that they would not have got Sean back without him, in The First Shall Be Last, then tells how, weeks after last seeing him, he opened an outhouse door in a dead-end town and found Trelawny inside with a newspaper, blaming a rotten oyster. Arthur: "Hey, maybe there are actually a hundred Trelawnys." Hosea: "What a terrible thought."
- Sheriff Gray. Dutch intends to go back and see him, since nobody knows who they are down here. Arthur did not find the sheriff or his deputy very sharp. Dutch: "If he thinks we can be useful to him, he can certainly be useful to us. A little hiding in plain sight." Arthur feels they are always hiding in plain sight; Dutch: "But sometimes more smartly than others."
- The bounty hunters. Dutch says he has had bounty hunters after him for years. Hosea: "Seems a little bigger now, Dutch." Dutch puts the "super agents" down to Trelawny "over-egging the pudding like the showman he is" and says he will do nothing until he has thought it through.
Gold Medal objectives
| # | Objective |
|---|---|
| 1 | Knock out Anders Anderson without taking a hit. |
| 2 | Catch and return Anders Anderson to jail within 5 minutes and 30 seconds. |
| 3 | Catch a fish with Dutch and Hosea. |
Blocking one of Anders's blows counts as being hit. Dodging backward, then grappling him and throwing him to the ground before punching, avoids his knife. If he does land a hit, dying restarts the checkpoint without losing that objective, at the cost of time for the second one.
Quotes
You a Scot?
Sheriff Leigh Gray, after Dutch introduces himself as Hoagy Macintosh. Dutch answers: "Partly... the best part."You are something else.
Arthur, to Archibald, who says he rides like his grandmotherTrelawny owes... everyone for something, but his information is good.
Hosea, on the ride to the fishing spotWorms are good for tiddlers like bluegill and rockbass, but you'd have to be real lucky to catch a sturgeon with one.
Hosea, in the boat, after Arthur asks what is wrong with a good old wormI enjoy picking on children...
Hosea, after Arthur tells him he is still too quick for him
Trivia
- Dutch introduces himself to the law as Hoagy Macintosh, and Arthur gives his name as Callahan. In American Distillation, Dutch presents him to the sheriff as "Arthur Callahan".
- Even if Arthur takes no damage in the fight with Anders, he still reacts afterward as if he had.
- While fishing, the talk can turn to old times. Dutch and Hosea recall an evening in 1884 when Arthur, sent out to fish, came back with three fine bass, until Dutch learned a week later that he had bought them from a fishmonger. Dutch also mentions that his mother is buried in Blackwater.
- "New South" is also a term of United States history for the Southern states after Reconstruction.



