American Distillation

Red Dead Redemption 2

Mission 5 of 18

Started by Dutch

Rhodes, Lemoyne

Available three in-game hours after The New South; can be played in a different order

"American Distillation" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2, in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is given by Dutch van der Linde, starts at the sheriff's office in Rhodes and takes place at Merkins Waller, in the Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne. It opens three in-game hours after The New South. This guide lists it fifth of the chapter's 18 missions; the chapter can be played in a different order.

Sheriff Leigh Gray makes Dutch, Arthur and Bill temporary deputies to help his deputy, Archibald MacGregor, shut down a moonshine still run for the Braithwaites. The raid brings in the buyers, the Lemoyne Raiders. Archibald then leaves most of the seized liquor to the gang.

Starting pointMission marker: Dutch
Map of the area around Rhodes, with the mission's starting point marked Rhodes
Location
Starts at the Scarlett Meadows Sheriff's Office in Rhodes; a moonshine still at Merkins Waller, Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne; ends at Clemens Point after a race, or in Scarlett Meadows
Rewards
A wagon of moonshine for the gang; a temporary deputy's badge, until the end of Chapter 3
Unlocks
Advertising, The New American Art, once The Course of True Love III and An American Pastoral Scene are also complete; An Honest Mistake (this mission or The Course of True Love II); Preaching Forgiveness as He Went, once two of The Course of True Love III, this mission and An American Pastoral Scene are complete; Sodom? Back to Gomorrah, after Preaching Forgiveness as He Went, once this mission is complete; the Stranger mission No Good Deed, after two more missions

Characters

The Braithwaites' moonshiners, among them Billy Lime, and the Lemoyne Raiders who buy their liquor.

Story

Deputies

Arthur walks into the sheriff's office in Rhodes, where Dutch is talking with Sheriff Gray. Dutch introduces him: "Oh, and here is my dear friend, Arthur Callahan. Boy is a hunter... boy is a killer." The sheriff tells Arthur they had a tough business, and that there is no need to pretend with him. He feels the men were hard done by, losing their employment like that, and says Rhodes has work enough for honest men.

Arthur is offered a drink: "That's some strong stuff." The sheriff steps out of the office for a moment. Dutch: "I told you we was moving up in this world. Deputies." Arthur: "You have finally lost your mind." Dutch answers that among "drunkards, hillbillies, and slavers", good honest thieves like them are bound to be the moralizers.

The sheriff comes back and explains the job: there is moonshine in the woods, costing the county its good name and the state a lot of income. If the men root it out, "maybe we'll make you permanent". He has to sit down. Dutch assures him he is in safe hands, and adds that people waste their time with the temperance movement: "Liquor never dulled a good man's senses." Outside, Dutch tells Arthur to ride with the deputy; he and Bill will follow.

A red-haired man with a long mustache, a checked shirt, a red neckerchief and a brown vest, standing in front of a pink clapboard wall and a white wooden porch
Leigh Gray, the sheriff of Rhodes, who deputizes the three men.

Archibald's chain of command

Archibald is waiting on the wagon. He asks whether Arthur's friend is behaving himself; Arthur says he thinks Trelawny has learned his lesson. Archibald congratulates him on becoming "a temporarily deputized... citizen of Scarlett Meadows County". Most towns get bounty hunters to do their dirty work, he says, but Sheriff Gray believes the law should keep the law. He reminds Arthur that there is a chain of command, and that he should follow his lead.

Arthur passes the message on to the riders behind: Archibald wants them to know he is in charge. Bill: "Of course." Dutch: "Who else would be?" Archibald adds that he put in a good word with the sheriff after the Anderson boys, in The New South; the others were rounded up soon after, and he is pushing for the rope.

The Braithwaites' moonshine

The moonshiners work for the Braithwaites, Archibald says. He describes them as an old cotton family who had a fortune until "a few changes in the labor laws", and who now deal in moonshine. Their stills are hidden all over Lemoyne, and as soon as one is destroyed another pops up. Catherine Braithwaite also has an expensive interest in thoroughbred horses to maintain.

Arthur asks about the gold the families are said to be fighting over. Archibald calls it a rumor: the Grays and the Braithwaites each think the other stole a fortune from them, but it was so long ago that he does not know whether it is true. Arthur: "Must be tough being rich, huh?" Behind them, Dutch tells Bill that the badge suits him and asks whether it feels good to be back serving his country. Bill: "I wouldn't go that far."

A dead legislator

Archibald stops the wagon next to a wrecked stagecoach. A man in a suit and tie lies dead, shot clean through the forehead. Archibald: "My money says this is the handiwork... of a gang called the Lemoyne Raiders." He takes the man's papers, asks Arthur to take the reins, and reads them as they go: the dead man is Fredrick Mitchell, a Lemoyne state legislator.

Archibald calls the Raiders a "bunch of ex-army free-staters without an ounce of respect for the law" who have murdered seven government officials this year alone. He says he knows the Braithwaites are in business with them: "Trash begets trash", as his Uncle Reginald, town preacher and town sheriff, used to say. He tells folks not even to look the Braithwaites in the eye.

The still at Merkins Waller

They reach the still in the swamp. Archibald wants everyone brought in alive, then the operation taken down for good. He calls the place "the rat's nest par excellence as they say in Paris" and starts talking about an aunt who went to Paris in '78. Dutch cuts him off and lets Arthur decide how to handle it. They split up: Arthur and Bill take the right, Dutch and Archibald the left.

Bill reminds Arthur that they need the moonshiners alive: "Let's just knock them out and tie 'em up." Arthur: "Got it, Deputy Williamson." They wait for the men to move, let a rider go, and take the others one by one without being seen. One moonshiner calls for a man named Anthony before Arthur takes him down. Arthur hogties one of the unconscious men, carries him to the wagon and drops him with the other captives.

Dynamite and the Lemoyne Raiders

Archibald says the still must be destroyed and asks whether any of the men can handle explosives. Arthur: "Sure, anyone but him." He promises it is the last time he will mention it; Bill: "Yeah, I'm sure." Arthur plants dynamite in the still. A band of riders arrives: "Hey, that belongs to the Lemoyne Raiders, you sons of bitches!" Arthur and Bill fight them off, then clear more Raiders coming up from the huts.

A wagon of moonshine

Back at the wagon, Dutch congratulates them and tells Archibald that he and his men must return to their lives. He notices that the last of the moonshine has not been destroyed and asks whether Archibald wants them to do it. Archibald says he normally takes it "for personal consumption", as part of the job, but he has to get home: he will take a jug or two and leave them the rest, "to show that there's no hard feelings... on account of the war". Dutch: "We are all Americans." Archibald quotes his cousin: "Some of us is not as American as others."

Archibald leaves with his prisoners, insulting one of them, Billy Lime. Dutch laughs that they have landed in a backwater so backward that "even we are like geniuses". He tells Bill to get the liquor out of there; Bill offers to stash it near camp, and Dutch tells him to show it to Hosea, who will find a use for it. The stash comes back in Advertising, The New American Art.

The young Dutch

Arthur rides back with Dutch. He says that, from what they were yelling, the Raiders were the buyers. Dutch: "Old Archibald didn't ask too many questions so neither should we." He finds the day worth the effort: "Deputized and hiding in plain sight." With the lawmen and the two families, he thinks they can play it from all sides: "It's got Hosea written all over it." Arthur: "This is starting to sound like the young Dutch again." Dutch protests that he is as strong as he has ever been, and challenges Arthur to a race back to camp.

During the race, Arthur taunts him: "I don't know who's more past it, you or your horse!" If Arthur wins, Dutch says he never knew Arthur was so good at running away; Arthur answers that he never knew age had slowed Dutch down so much. Dutch: "Well, time is a bastard." He tells Arthur he had fun with him today, then: "I was gonna say you're like a son to me... but you're more than that." The mission ends there.

Mission failure

The mission fails if the player:

  • assaults, kills or abandons Dutch, Bill or Archibald, or lets one of them be killed;
  • alerts the moonshiners too early;
  • kills any of the captured moonshiners;
  • destroys or disables the wagon;
  • kills or abandons his horse;
  • dies.

Deaths

  • Fredrick Mitchell and a companion, killed by the Lemoyne Raiders before the wagon arrives.
  • Several Lemoyne Raiders, killed by Arthur and Bill.
Choices and variants

Have you met the Raiders?

Arthur's lines at the stagecoach depend on whether he has already met the Lemoyne Raiders, in free roam or in Further Questions of Female Suffrage. If he has, he says he has run into them, and later that they are not the nicest fellows in his experience. If not, he compliments Archibald on his "keen eye", then remarks that the local lawmen have their work cut out for them.

The takedowns

The takedown prompts are not required. The moonshiners can also be dealt with silently from a distance, with throwing knives, tomahawks, hatchets, cleavers or a bow with quiet arrows, or caught with the lasso.

Racing Dutch or not

The race back to camp can be accepted or declined. If Arthur loses, the dialogue at the finish changes. If he does not race, the player can follow Bill instead: he drives the moonshine wagon to a spot near camp, parks it and walks in.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Win the race back to camp.
2Complete the mission without taking any damage.
3Get 10 headshots.
4Complete with at least 70% accuracy.

The fight with the Raiders has no time limit: staying in cover and using Dead Eye helps avoid damage. Shortcuts straight to camp, instead of the suggested route, help win the race.

Quotes
  • No man owes another anything.
    Sheriff Leigh Gray, to Arthur, in his office
  • These damn flies, I swear they've got it in for me.
    Bill, when the wagon stops by the stagecoach. Dutch answers: "You could try washing once in a while."
  • Even saying that word makes me sick.
    Archibald, on the Braithwaites, on arrival at the still
  • Let's stop these filthy degenerate tax dodgers. The cheek of them.
    Dutch, before the group splits up at the still
  • Oh, I'm going to enjoy wiping that smirk off your face!
    Dutch, during the race back to camp
Trivia
  • In Chapter 1, in Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?, the charge meant to stop Cornwall's train failed to go off when Bill pushed the plunger.
  • After the mission, a notice reminds the player not to use force or cause trouble in Rhodes, since Arthur is acting as a deputy for Sheriff Gray. The badge cannot be kept: it is lost at the end of Chapter 3.
  • Shooting a still releases steam that can knock Arthur, or an enemy, to the ground.
  • The wrecked stagecoach and Mitchell's body are still on the road during the race, and disappear as soon as the mission ends.