The Course of True Love I
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 3 of 18
Available after The New South; can be played in a different order
"The Course of True Love I" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It starts and ends at Caliga Hall, the Gray plantation, and opens a five-part strand: parts I to III are played in Chapter 3, parts IV and V in Chapter 6. It becomes available after The New South. This guide lists it third of the chapter's 18 missions, which can be played in a different order.
Dutch sends Arthur Morgan to look around Caliga Hall. Arthur gets past the guards by invoking the sheriff and meets Beau Gray, the son of Tavish Gray. Beau is in love with Penelope Braithwaite, from the rival family, and offers to pay Arthur to carry her a letter and a bracelet.

- Location
- Caliga Hall, the Gray family's tobacco plantation in Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne, between Rhodes and Saint Denis
- Unlocks
- The Course of True Love II, which continues straight on with the delivery to Braithwaite Manor
Started by
Dutch sends Arthur to Caliga Hall to find out about the Grays; the errand for Penelope is Beau's.
Story
At the gate of Caliga Hall
Dutch asks Arthur to go to Caliga Hall and find out what he can about the Grays. The family owns the tobacco plantation, in Bayou Nwa, between Rhodes and Saint Denis, and holds the law in Rhodes through Sheriff Leigh Gray.
Armed men guard the front entrance. One of them stops Arthur: "What you want, boy? This is private property, interlopers are not permitted." Arthur asks whether this is the Gray plantation. The guard confirms it and adds: "Yup. Caliga Hall. And that's as close as you're getting to it."
Arthur claims to be on the sheriff's business: "Sheriff's orders. He wanted me to have a word with some folk on the property. I'm recently deputized, you see." The guard lets him in, without much conviction: "Deputized? And I suppose Leigh was drunk when he did it... look, you can come in, but you ain't talking with me."
A talker named Beau
The objective is to ask around the estate about the Grays. Arthur tries a man at work: "Hey, can you talk?" The worker sends him elsewhere: "I look like I can talk? You want a talker, try Beau Gray. Out by the store houses. Man won't lift a hand, but sure can move his lips."
Arthur finds Beau and opens with a question: "I see you at the Sheriff's Office?" Beau calls him "friend". He has noticed that, in a place that sees few traveling men, "a whole phalanx of mysterious... but strangely helpful Yankees" has turned up in the area.
Arthur says he is only looking for work. Beau does not believe him: "Well, looking for something. Don't worry, your secret's safe with me." He adds that he has a secret of his own. Arthur asks: "Are you secretly normal?" Beau goes on: he does not care if Arthur kills "the whole lot of us... and the Braithwaites".
Beau and Penelope
Beau confesses that he is in love with Penelope, and that it is impossible: she is a Braithwaite. He introduces himself: "I'm Beau Gray, son of Tavish Gray... nephew of Leigh Gray the sheriff... grandson of old Murdo Gray." He explains that the Grays have been the Braithwaites' murderers for so long that nobody can say why any more. He describes Penelope: "She's like a woman from the future. She's like... tomorrow, if tomorrow turns out fine."
Beau asks for help. Arthur first refuses: "I don't wanna get involved in gang feuds... it seems unseemly." Beau offers to pay: "We Grays, we've always got money... no brains, mind, but money." Arthur accepts the job.
Beau tells him that Penelope likes to sit in the gazebo on the edge of the Braithwaite property, and hands him a letter and a bracelet for her. He warns him about the Braithwaite guards: "they're worse with strangers than ours are!" The delivery is The Course of True Love II.
Choices and variants
The fleeing man
As Arthur rides up to Caliga Hall, the guards are shooting at a man who runs off and jumps the fence. Arthur can lasso him; one of the Grays then compliments his rope work, and a guard picks the man up and carries him off over his shoulder. A guard followed afterwards only walks the grounds for a few minutes, then stops at the stable with the man still on his shoulder.
Beau's bracelet
The bracelet can be sold to a fence before it reaches Penelope. The sale lowers Arthur's honor slightly, and Penelope's lines change in part II.
Order of play
- The mission becomes available after The New South, like American Distillation; the two can be played in either order.
- Parts I and II follow each other without a break: Beau's errand leads straight to Braithwaite Manor.
Quotes
Not yet, but here's hoping.
Beau, when Arthur asks whether they are friendsI don't wanna kill anyone.
Arthur, to BeauWell, love tends to be complicated.
Arthur, when Beau says his love is impossibleWell, I'm sorry for your predicament.
Arthur, after Beau has described Penelope
Trivia
- The title quotes Shakespeare: "The course of true love never did run smooth" is Lysander's line in A Midsummer Night's Dream (Act 1, Scene 1).
- Beau is first seen at the sheriff's office in Rhodes at the end of The New South. Taking leave of the gang, Sheriff Leigh Gray turns to him: "Is it true you were seen talking to that wretched Penelope Braithwaite?"
- Beau Gray is played by Bjorn Thorstad, according to the game's credits.
- Caliga Hall, visited here for the first time in the story, is also the setting of The Fine Joys of Tobacco, in which Arthur and Sean set fire to the Grays' tobacco fields.
