The Fine Joys of Tobacco
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 12 of 18
Available after Advertising, The New American Art (after Magicians for Sport: two in-game hours later if two or more missions are open); can be played in a different order
"The Fine Joys of Tobacco" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is given by Hosea Matthews and opens after Advertising, The New American Art. It starts at Braithwaite Manor and takes place at Caliga Hall, the Grays' plantation in Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne. This guide lists it twelfth of the chapter's 18 missions, which can be played in a different order.
Catherine Braithwaite wants the Grays' tobacco fields burned with the rest of the moonshine, and Arthur Morgan and Sean MacGuire take the job. Sean drives the wagon into Caliga Hall with Arthur hidden in the back. At nightfall, they douse the fields and a barn, set them alight and escape on the horses of a payroll wagon, with the payroll.

- Location
- Starts at Braithwaite Manor, Scarlett Meadows; Caliga Hall, Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne; ends at the Clemens Point camp
- Unlocks
- Fire Bottle (weapon); Horse Flesh for Dinner (after one in-game hour); with Friends in Very Low Places, Blessed are the Peacemakers and Horse Flesh for Dinner, A Short Walk in a Pretty Town
Story
Cribbage at Braithwaite Manor
After Advertising, The New American Art, Dutch has told Arthur to meet Hosea and Sean at Braithwaite Manor. Arthur tells the guards at the gate: "Hey fellers, I have a meeting with Mrs. Braithwaite. My associates are already here." A doorman shows him into the house, where Catherine, Hosea and Sean are playing cribbage while one of her sons looks on.
Catherine looks Arthur over: "So this one... he as big and as dumb as he looks?" Hosea answers with a joke: "Well, he's surely big... but his intelligence is a matter of some conjecture. Some say he is as dumb as he looks... but, I think... well, he's not quite that dumb." Catherine asks whether these are the men going to Caliga Hall; Hosea says they could take care of it, but raises the question of money.
Catherine laughs and says the family has money. Hosea asks: "Paper? Bonds? Metal?" Her son calls Hosea a "Yankee numbskull": she will not pay with a certified check. Hosea answers him through his mother: "Ain't childbirth just the most beautiful miracle? Seems a lady can birth monkeys after all." Arthur and Sean then head outside.
The road to Caliga Hall
Outside, a wagon loaded with moonshine is waiting. Sean offers to fill Arthur in on the way, but Arthur insists on driving. Arthur remarks that Sean was quiet in there; Sean says it took everything he had, and says what he thinks of her son.
Sean explains the job: Catherine wants the Grays' tobacco fields torched, and it has not rained in weeks. They will use the moonshine in the back: "Burns faster than kerosene, that stuff." She told Sean that it would be "fitting". Sean then says what he thinks of Catherine herself, which makes Arthur laugh. Hosea, Sean says, reckons one of the two families has gold stashed somewhere. Sean has also heard that Old Man Gray has doubled security since the business at the saloon.
Sean's plan is simple. Wagons go in and out of the estate all the time with supplies, equipment and payroll, all the more since the Grays have taken on extra men: "We're making a delivery, that's all. Just leave it to me. I can talk a dog off a meat wagon." On the way, Sean points out that the Grays know Arthur. Arthur agrees, hands him the reins and hides in the back of the wagon. Sean promises to try to act naturally; Arthur tells him: "Try and do an impression of a human being."
Hamish
At the gate, a Gray guard stops the wagon: "You're not the usual driver." Sean offers him a drink and says he is new, from Donegal, in Ireland, sent up with this load after some incident at the saloon in town. The guard, Hamish, climbs aboard to show him the way. He says his people come from Scotland; Sean answers: "Then, you and I are nearly brothers."
On the way, Hamish complains that Mr. Gray has "a heap of problems right now with another family round here", people trying to sabotage his livelihood. He has Sean drive the wagon into a wagon shed to unload it. There Sean keeps him talking about the big houses of Donegal while Arthur climbs out of the back and kills him from behind. Sean and Arthur close the doors and wait for dark.
Moonshine on the fields
At night, Sean gets the fire bottles ready. Arthur splits the work: Sean will go to the dry barn, while Arthur deals with the fields. They will coat everything in moonshine, then light it with the bottles. Before they head out the back, Sean says: "I'm rebel stock, boy... I was born burning down manor houses." Arthur answers: "Well burn quietly."
A wagon drives in and they hide. Its driver tells a guard that he is bringing tools and payroll, and is told to drop it by the supply shed at the back of the fields. Sean notices: "You hear that? Payroll." Arthur wants the job done first. Sean leaves for the barn, and Arthur creeps through the crops, pouring moonshine on each field while avoiding the patrols.
Fire
Arthur joins Sean at the barn. Sean gives it a dousing too, and Arthur throws a fire bottle into it. Sean cheers ("Woohoo, would you look at that!") and asks for more bottles on the fields. The guards see the fire and open fire on the two men. The horses Sean meant to take from the stables bolt; Arthur: "There goes our ride out of here!"
Sean remembers the wagon that came in earlier: they can take its horses. The two men shoot their way through the burning fields to the supply wagon. Arthur cuts the horses free while Sean checks whether the payroll is still inside. He finds it, and they ride off, killing more guards on the way out.
After the fire
On the way out, Sean says: "That Braithwaite hag got her money's worth alright!" Once they have lost their pursuers, he finds it an interesting little fight that Dutch has put them in the middle of. Arthur hopes that Dutch and Hosea are right and that there is some money at the end of it.
Sean asks what now. Arthur can ride back to the Clemens Point camp with him or stay behind. If they ride back together, Sean announces "Here we are, home sweet home", and Arthur asks him to let Hosea know how it went.
Choices and variants
Before the mission
- Before starting the mission, Arthur can steal the moonshine wagon and sell it to Seamus at the wagon fence.
- Braithwaite Manor can be explored during the mission, after the opening cutscene.
- If Arthur ignores the doorman and does not go in, the doorman has seven different lines.
- If Horse Flesh for Dinner has already been played, Arthur tells Sean on the road: "We just robbed their horses too." Sean answers: "That was you? Jesus."
Hamish
- Hamish can be killed silently by Arthur or by Sean, or knocked out by Arthur with the butt of his pistol.
- If Arthur kills Hamish before Sean does, the next cutscene still shows his body outside with a stab wound, as if Sean had killed him.
- Hamish cannot be looted: the cutscene starts moments after he dies.
Lighting the fields
Volatile fire bottles and incendiary rounds do not set the tobacco alight: only regular fire bottles fulfil the objective.
Mission failure
The mission fails if Arthur attacks, kills or abandons Sean, lets him die, attacks anyone or uses a weapon at Braithwaite Manor, destroys or disables the moonshine wagon, alerts the Gray guards before the firefight, runs out of moonshine while dousing the fields, kills an escape horse, or dies.
Gold Medal objectives
| # | Objective |
|---|---|
| 1 | Silently kill the Gray that Sean distracts in the wagon store. |
| 2 | Douse the fields within 2 minutes and 20 seconds. |
| 3 | Kill 5 Grays during the escape. |
| 4 | Complete the mission without taking any health items. |
For the dousing, it is faster to start on the nearest field as soon as the wagon has passed, moving crouched and without stopping in cover; once a field is doused, its marked area disappears from the map. During the escape, Sean shoots with high accuracy: riding ahead of him leaves more Grays for Arthur. Chewing tobacco or Snake Oil taken beforehand keeps Dead Eye available.
Quotes
The master finagler of nothing!
Sean, about Hosea; Arthur answers: "Easy, easy."I'm not gonna go that far.
Sean, when Arthur tells him to impersonate a human beingHosea better get us paid real well for this.
Arthur, during the firefightThis is what it's all about, hey, Arthur?
Sean, during the escape; Arthur answers: "Glad you're having fun."Jesus, that turned into a right party!
Sean, riding out of Caliga Hall; Arthur answers: "You call that a party?"
Trivia
- Sean is not available at camp while this mission is waiting to be played.
- Sean tells Hamish that he comes from Donegal, then compares Caliga Hall to Connemara, both in Ireland.
- When the payroll wagon arrives, the Gray guard says he thought the wagon had already come in; its driver answers: "This one didn't."
- Burning tobacco fields appear in a Red Dead Redemption 2 trailer.



