Magicians for Sport

Red Dead Redemption 2

Mission 11 of 18

Started by Dutch

Clemens Point, Lemoyne

Available after Advertising, The New American Art, one in-game hour later and 300 m away from camp; can be played in a different order

"Magicians for Sport" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is given by Dutch van der Linde and opens after Advertising, The New American Art. It takes place in and around Rhodes, in Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne. This guide lists it eleventh of the chapter's 18 missions, which can be played in a different order.

Arthur Morgan and Charles Smith go to check on Josiah Trelawny, who has warned the gang about bounty hunters. His caravan has been ransacked. They follow the trail, question two men in the woods and free Trelawny from Cole Stoudemire's bounty hunters, in the cornfields near Braithwaite Manor. Trelawny then moves in with the gang.

Starting pointMission marker: Dutch
Map of the area around Clemens Point, with the mission's starting point marked Clemens Point
Location
Starts at the Clemens Point camp; Trelawny's caravan on the edge of Rhodes; the woods nearby; a farm by the cornfields near Braithwaite Manor, Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne
Unlocks
After one in-game hour: Friends in Very Low Places (with Further Questions of Female Suffrage; also if Further Questions of Female Suffrage is the only mission left open) and Blessed are the Peacemakers (with Sodom? Back to Gomorrah). The Fine Joys of Tobacco opens directly after Advertising, The New American Art; after this mission, it comes two in-game hours later if two or more missions are open

Characters

At camp

Seven bounty hunters working for Cole Stoudemire: two in the woods, three in the cornfields, two in the barn. Cole Stoudemire himself is only named.

Story

Dutch's orders

At camp, Arthur asks Dutch whether he is sweating yet about what Trelawny said about bounty hunters. Dutch first complains about the place: "We're in some disease-ridden, swampy, dixie-whistling shithole." He answers: "Not sweating as such, but maybe a little gentle perspiration." He sends Arthur to find out exactly what Trelawny knows and who he spoke to. He tells him to take Charles: "Oh, the sight of the pair of you would make a statue sing out its secrets."

On the way, Arthur explains that he and Dutch are working for the Rhodes sheriff; "hiding in plain sight", as Dutch calls it. Charles finds it strange that the bounty hunters are still after them: "We didn't even get away with the money!" Arthur answers: "Yeah, but they don't know that." Charles has met Trelawny only a couple of times and finds him strange; Arthur calls him "just a cockroach in fancy britches" who gets into places the others cannot.

The ransacked caravan

Trelawny rents a caravan on the edge of Rhodes. Someone has got there first. Inside, Arthur notices that the food is barely touched and the bed is not made, so Trelawny left in a hurry, not long ago. He finds blood on the floor. Charles reads a big struggle, about twelve hours old, but there is no body. Charles then finds tracks.

A wooden caravan with a curved roof and a porch of green steps, a man in a red waistcoat and a hat reading on the porch, a barrel and a lantern beside the steps
Trelawny's rented caravan on the edge of Rhodes, with Trelawny reading on the porch.

Tracking the kidnappers

Charles lets Arthur lead the tracking. Arthur notes that this is not the kind of place he would expect Trelawny to stay; Charles says he normally scams his way into the best hotel in town. Charles remembers riding with Javier and Trelawny to get Sean after the bar fight, in The First Shall Be Last: Trelawny talked the whole way and said nothing. The trail leads into the forest.

In the woods, two men sit at a camp. Arthur asks whether they have seen a strange sort of fellow, "sort of formal". One answers: "Strange, sure. Formal, no." Charles has spotted a walking cane beside them: "He uses a cane, looks a lot like this one." The two men turn hostile, and Arthur and Charles beat them with their fists.

A small camp under a grey tarpaulin in a sunlit forest, a man lying on a bedroll and a gray-haired man in a white shirt and red waistcoat sitting hunched on a stool beside him, a saddled horse on the right
The two bounty hunters' camp in the woods, where Arthur and Charles find Trelawny's cane.

Arthur questions one of them. The man refuses at first, then gives in: "They took him to a cabin, over by the cornfields." Asked which cornfields, he says: "Left... down the path there... by Braithwaite Manor." Arthur lets him run off. Charles thinks he knows a way around so that they do not have to cross the Braithwaites' land; Arthur agrees, having spent enough time there.

On the ride, Charles asks what the bounty hunters want with Trelawny and whether he will talk. Arthur is sure he will: "He'd sell his own sister to save a train fare!" He does not think Trelawny knows where the gang is holed up. Charles wonders why Dutch still deals with him. Arthur says loyalty matters to Dutch, and that Trelawny, for all his trouble, always ends up bringing them something big.

The cornfields

At a small cabin on the edge of a field, two men are bringing a beaten Trelawny out. Arthur stops them: "Put the man down, gentlemen." The bounty hunters run into the cornfields. When Arthur says "So you're alive.", Trelawny answers: "Allegedly." He sends Arthur after them: "Go get them, Arthur. I can handle this. Go deal with them, my brothers!"

Arthur and Charles search the corn and kill two of the bounty hunters. Charles points out some birds: the last man has dumped his gear and cannot be far. The third bounty hunter surprises Arthur and holds him hostage. When Charles comes up, the man offers him money to walk away: "He's not your friend... I'll give you money..." Charles answers "Oh be quiet" and kills him with a thrown knife.

Arthur thanks him. Gunshots then come from a barn: more bounty hunters are inside. Arthur and Charles shoot their way in until Charles reckons the last of them is down.

Trelawny's account

Arthur and Charles walk back to Trelawny, who has made himself comfortable. Asked how he is, he says: "Never finer." He explains that the kidnappers were bounty hunters attached to Cole Stoudemire, and that they were not looking for him as such. He says he told them little: that he was an intellectual from Oregon, looking for a job at the university. He adds that the gang stirred up "quite a hornet's nest in Blackwater".

Trelawny cannot go back to his caravan and asks to stay with the gang for a while. Arthur sends Charles back to camp with him and stays behind. Arthur stays alone. With high honor, he says: "It always seem to be more... more and more civilization. I wanna get back in the open country, or the west, or... what's left of it, but... even that ain't the way I remember it." With low honor, he notes instead that there is more civilization wherever the gang goes, and that this may be how things will be from now on.

Choices and variants

The two men in the woods

  • Killing both men before questioning them fails the mission.
  • Shooting one of the two men before walking up to their camp skips the fistfight and triggers a different cutscene, at a cost in honor; the survivor uses the same lines. Shooting near them without hitting anyone triggers yet another cutscene.
  • One of the two, Jeb, can be killed by Arthur at the camp.

Loot and missable items

  • The Mine Share and the Rare Rolling Block Rifle can be missed in this mission. The rifle is looted from a bounty hunter in the barn.
  • Each bounty hunter carries about 20 dollars, far more than most enemies; looting all seven bodies brings in about 150 dollars.

Mission failure

The mission fails if Arthur attacks, kills or abandons Charles, lets him die, attacks or kills Trelawny, kills the two men before questioning them, alerts the law, kills or abandons his horse, or dies.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Inspect all the clues in Trelawny's caravan.
2While tracking, stay within 30 feet of Trelawny's trail.
3Kill 2 bounty hunters in the cornfields within 1 minute.
4Complete the mission without taking any health items.

The three clues in the caravan are the half-eaten meal on the table, the bed and the blood on the floor. In the corn, shots fired while a bounty hunter crosses open ground are more reliable than shots through the stalks.

Quotes
  • On the run from one bunch of lawmen, working for another. Interesting.
    Charles, on the way to Rhodes
  • By the looks of things, it wasn't a social call.
    Charles, at the caravan
  • He somehow manages to be both lucky and unlucky at the same time.
    Arthur, about Trelawny
  • You should have taken the money.
    Arthur to Charles, who answers: "I know, I'm a fool."
  • What's government agents and bounty hunters to us?
    Arthur, walking back to Trelawny
Trivia
  • Trelawny's caravan stands near the fence in the north of Rhodes. In 1907 it can still be visited, run down and without a tenant.
  • Throwing a Fire Bottle or dynamite before going back into the cornfield for the third bounty hunter skips the hostage cutscene, but the mission then stops progressing.
  • In the barn, Charles's attacks do no damage to the last two bounty hunters. Arthur can disarm them with his fists; led to Charles, they fight him hand to hand and can kill him.