Further Questions of Female Suffrage
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 2 of 18
Available from the start of Chapter 3
"Further Questions of Female Suffrage" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 and one of the two missions that open Chapter 3: Clemens Point, the other being The New South. It starts at the camp kitchen, where Simon Pearson and Sadie Adler are arguing, and takes place in Rhodes, in Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne. On the official guide's chart, it opens after A Strange Kindness, with the note "350m away from camp". This guide lists it second of the chapter's 18 missions; the chapter can be played in a different order.
Sadie refuses to spend her days cooking, so Arthur takes her into Rhodes to buy supplies for Pearson and post one of his letters. On the road back, a band of Lemoyne Raiders demands a toll, and Sadie answers with her gun.

- Location
- Starts and ends at the Clemens Point camp; Rhodes (general store and the post office at the station), Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne
- Unlocks
- Friends in Very Low Places, together with Magicians for Sport (Friends in Very Low Places also opens if Magicians for Sport is complete and this mission is the only one available)
Story
Trouble in the kitchen
At Clemens Point, Arthur walks up to Pearson's kitchen in the middle of a fight. Sadie: "Say whatever you damn well please... but I tell you, if I don't get out of here soon, I'm going to kill somebody." Pearson answers that if she does not stop hissing at him, he will kill her. Pearson then tells her to put her knife down or lose a hand.
Arthur asks what is wrong with them. Sadie: "I ain't chopping vegetables for a living." Arthur asks, mocking her, whether there were not enough feathers in her pillow. She says she is not lazy and will work, but not at this. When Arthur asks whether cooking is not work, she explains that she and her husband shared all the work: she was out in the fields, she can hunt, carry a knife or use a gun. If he keeps her at camp, she will skin "this fat old coot" and serve him for dinner.
Arthur stops them: "Enough! Both of ya." He tells Sadie that if she wants to ride with the men, so be it, but they do more than hunt: they are hunted, "and them things hunting us... well they got guns of their own." Sadie: "I ain't afraid of dying." Arthur asks Pearson whether he needs anything. Pearson hands him his shopping list and a letter to post in town. Arthur: "Sure. Come on, princess."
Pearson's letter
Arthur drives the wagon. Sadie: "So I've graduated from chopping vegetables to shopping?" Arthur tells her to shut her mouth. A little later he asks whether she has cooled down. She says she is no scullion and will not take orders from "that sweating halfwit". Arthur: "Well, I guess we all gotta do our share, Princess."
Sadie asks for the letter. Arthur: "Oh, you reading his mail now?" Sadie: "Oh, robbing and killing's okay, but letter reading's where we draw the line?" He hands it over, and she reads it aloud in an imitation of Pearson. It is addressed to his aunt Cathy. She finds most of it boring, then reads two lines that make them both laugh: Pearson writes that he has "traveled widely, making no small name for myself", and that he has not yet taken a wife, though not "for a lack of suitors".
Sadie asks whether Pearson has ever talked to a woman he has not paid. Arthur: "Look, we're all hiding behind something..." She then notices the return name on the envelope, Tacitus Kilgore. Arthur explains that it is Dutch's idea: all mail goes to the same alias, and whenever the gang settles somewhere new, Strauss goes into town and tells them to expect mail under the name Tacitus Kilgore, or whatever the name has become. He takes the letter back as they reach Rhodes.
Shopping in Rhodes
They stop near the general store. Sadie asks what the plan is, and suggests she shoots the shopkeeper. Arthur: "No. You insane?" When she says she thought they were outlaws, he answers: "Outlaws... not idiots. We rob fools that rob other people. These people, they're just trying to get by." He sends her in to buy food, without guns: "There'll be time for killing soon enough."
Sadie goes into the store while Arthur walks to the train station to post the letter. On the way he passes two townsmen, one of whom will only say that his parcel holds some ointment "for a private matter". At the counter, Arthur asks the clerk to post the letter.
Back at the wagon, Arthur finds Sadie scolding the store clerk, who is loading the crates: "I've birthed foals with more strength than you." She gives him a tip, then takes it back when he only thanks her. Arthur lets her drive. When he calls her "lady", she answers: "I like Sadie, not lady."
The harmonica
On the way home, Arthur notices her new clothes. Sadie: "Don't start. I can wear what I damn well want." She repeats that she and her husband shared all the work, and that she was never "some little wife with a flower in her hair baking cherry pies all day". Arthur says she looks the part now, and that it will not be long before she is smoking cigars and playing the harmonica.
Sadie answers that she used to love playing the harmonica, before her house and everything she owned were burned to the ground. Arthur says he is sorry and that he may keep an eye out for another one. Sadie: "I don't want no pity. Just treat me equal and know... nobody's taking nothing from me ever again." Arthur: "Just don't kill the camp cook... please."
The Lemoyne Raiders' toll
Riders come up beside the wagon. Their spokesman tells Arthur they are in Lemoyne Raider country and must pay a toll to pass. Arthur tells Sadie to keep it cool, then refuses. The rider orders him to pull over. Sadie: "Hey, how's about this?" She shoots him, then urges the horses on: "Go, go, go!"
More Raiders give chase, and Arthur fires back from the wagon. He asks what that was; Sadie answers that they were going to rob them. Arthur: "A new pair of pants and you think you're Landon Ricketts." Sadie runs one of the riders down with the wagon. Arthur: "Well you wanted to see some action, lady, now you got your wish!" Once the last ones flee, Sadie compliments his shooting and offers to drive them back; Arthur takes the reins: "Because you've caused enough trouble already."
Arthur tells her she did well, but that it is a lot of mess to make near camp, and he hopes it does not bring anyone sniffing around. Sadie asks whether he will tell Dutch. Arthur: "Maybe, if he asks. But maybe not." He asks her not to rib Pearson about the letter; she promises, then quotes it again. Arthur says he will not be giving her any mail to post soon. Sadie would like a peek at his journal; Arthur: "Not a chance..."
Back at camp
Pearson greets them: "You didn't get yourself killed then, Miss Adler?" Sadie: "Not quite." She tells Arthur she enjoyed herself out there. Arthur says Mrs. Adler did okay; Pearson: "At shopping?" Arthur: "Yes, at shopping..." They help Pearson unload the wagon.
Sadie thanks Arthur. He answers: "I would ride with you again, Mrs. Adler... if you will ride with me." Sadie: "Maybe... if you prove you can handle yourself." Arthur: "Well, they say I lack finesse, but... I ain't afraid of gun smoke." Pearson thanks Arthur for the favor, and adds for Sadie: "And... nice pants, by the way." Sadie: "Oh, shut up." The mission ends there.
Mission failure
The mission fails if the player:
- assaults, kills or abandons Sadie, or lets her be killed;
- alerts the law, or annoys the shop owner;
- leaves Rhodes;
- destroys or disables the wagon;
- annoys the people at camp on the way back, for example by running them over;
- dies.
Deaths
- Up to ten Lemoyne Raiders, killed by Arthur and Sadie.
Choices and variants
Following Sadie into the store
If the player follows Sadie into the general store instead of going to the post office, she and Arthur act like a married couple, and she gives the clerk the name Mrs. Kilgore, after the gang's mail alias, Tacitus Kilgore.
Gold Medal objectives
| # | Objective |
|---|---|
| 1 | Fend off the Lemoyne Raiders in less than 1 minute. |
| 2 | Get 5 headshots. |
| 3 | Complete with at least 85% accuracy. |
| 4 | Complete the mission without taking any health items. |
Quotes
Come near me, sailor... and I will slice you up!
Sadie, to Pearson, at the start of the argumentYou are something else...
Arthur, as Sadie starts reading Pearson's letter in his voiceRemind me not to get on your bad side.
Arthur, to Sadie, after the Raiders' attackWell, I'd like to say I missed your refined conversations, but... I'd be lying.
Pearson, to Sadie, back at camp
Trivia
- Arthur's line about Landon Ricketts names the gunslinger of Red Dead Redemption (1911), whom John Marston meets in Mexico. See Landon Ricketts.
- After the mission, Sadie stands guard around camp, armed with a Carbine Repeater.
- When Arthur goes back to the general store later, the clerk can comment on Sadie's new clothes, though he still calls her "Arthur's friend".


