An Honest Mistake

Red Dead Redemption 2

Mission 7 of 18

Started by Molly and Uncle

Clemens Point, Lemoyne

Available after The Course of True Love II or American Distillation; can be played in a different order

"An Honest Mistake" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2, in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is given by Molly O'Shea and Uncle at the Clemens Point camp and takes place around Compson's Stead, in Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne. It becomes available after The Course of True Love II or American Distillation. This guide lists it 7th of the chapter's 18 missions; the chapter can be played in a different order.

Uncle brings in a tip about a supply wagon he believes is briefly unguarded. Arthur Morgan, Charles Smith, Bill Williamson and Uncle stop it, but the wagon belongs to Cornwall Kerosene & Tar. Leviticus Cornwall's guards chase them to a barn, where they hide until nightfall. The guards find them there, and the four fight their way out as the barn burns.

Starting pointMission marker: Molly
Map of the area around Clemens Point, with the mission's starting point marked Clemens Point
Location
Starts at the Clemens Point camp; a crossroads near an old ruined church; Compson's Stead, Scarlett Meadows, Lemoyne
Rewards
A share of the money taken from the wagon
Unlocks
The stranger mission The Iniquities of History (Jeremiah Compson, in Rhodes); Preaching Forgiveness as He Went, once two of The Course of True Love III, American Distillation and An American Pastoral Scene are complete

Started by

Molly calls Arthur over; Uncle interrupts her with the tip that starts the job.

Characters

At camp

The wagon drivers, Cornwall's guards (among them Lowe and Cooperforth) and a squatter living in the Compson house.

Story

Molly and Uncle at camp

At Clemens Point, Molly calls Arthur over for a quick word and asks him to call her Molly. She wants to know how Dutch seems to him. Arthur answers that he seems about the same as usual. Molly says she really loves Dutch, then starts to repeat his saying that loyalty is everything, without finishing her sentence.

Uncle cuts in, excuses himself to Miss O'Shea and announces "the great gift of information." Arthur guesses that Uncle wants him to risk his neck while Uncle lounges around, and tells him to find another fool. Uncle then calls Bill and Charles over as his "other fool", and tells them Arthur is above a little stick-up. Arthur says he is not, and agrees to go on one condition: Uncle rides with them.

Uncle first pleads a serious medical condition. Arthur: "Yes, you are a compulsive liar." Uncle turns to Charles and asks whether he has ever lied to him. Charles: "I hardly know you." Uncle insists that the job is easy, that he will only take a small commission for his information and that it is now or never. Arthur: "Then it's never." Uncle gives in and agrees to come, then explains the job: a supply wagon carrying payroll, unguarded for a short time as it passes a crossroads near an old ruined church, before it joins the rest of the wagon train. He calls it very easy pickings.

The crossroads

On the ride, Bill asks how Uncle heard of the job when they have only been in the area a short while. Uncle answers that he has been getting down to business while the others were fishing or playing lawmen; Bill suggests he was finding the nearest grog house. Uncle claims he has been scoping jobs like this since they were children. Arthur: "Once a decade, maybe."

They stop near the crossroads. Charles says they should cover their faces and asks to keep it quiet and clean, since nobody needs to die. The wagon arrives on time. Bill orders the driver to stop and warns him not to try anything. The driver says he does not want to be shot, but that this is a mistake: he works for Cornwall Kerosene and Tar, for Mr. Leviticus Cornwall. Bill answers that Cornwall is rich enough to share and not miss it. The driver: "Oh, he'll miss it."

Arthur and Charles go through the wagon and take the money. Bill spots something on the road: a guard shouts that the wagon is being robbed, and a large group of Cornwall's men rides in. The four gang members flee on horseback.

The chase

Arthur shoots back at the riders. Bill: "Nice going, Uncle! Most guarded wagon in goddamn history." Uncle: "How was I to know?" Uncle wants to leave the trail, lose the guards in the woods and head back to camp. Arthur refuses: they cannot risk leading Cornwall's men to the camp, so they must find a place to lie low.

They reach an old homestead, Compson's Stead, and hide in a barn on the edge of the property. Charles and Arthur send their horses away. Arthur decides they will stay out of sight until dark, then sneak away; Charles keeps watch while the others rest.

A weathered wooden barn with a rusted tin roof on a grassy slope, with crates and a blue cart in front of it
The barn at Compson's Stead where the four men hide.

The barn at nightfall

When night comes, Arthur says it is time to go, but Charles sees a light by the house. Cornwall's guards have arrived. Arthur tells the others to keep this calm. One of the guards orders whoever is inside the house to come out. A squatter living there answers that he has nothing to rob. Pressed to say what he heard, he admits that there were maybe some noises out by the barn a while ago. The guard sends two of his men, Cooperforth and Lowe, to check the barn.

The two guards head for the barn. The gang tries to stay hidden as they come in, but Bill knocks over a bucket, and the fight starts. More guards attack from every side. Bill notes that Cornwall "really don't like getting robbed". Charles asks: "How about we stop robbing Cornwall for a while?" Uncle answers that he did not know they were robbing Cornwall.

A smashed lantern sets the barn on fire during the shootout. Arthur warns that they will be "charcoal" if they do not get out soon. The four climb out of the burning barn, and Bill leads them into the trees to lose the guards.

Two by two in the woods

Uncle suggests splitting up to confuse the pursuers: Arthur goes with him, Charles with Bill. Charles warns Bill that if he does anything dumb, he is on his own. Behind a group of rocks, Arthur proposes to take two guards quietly, Uncle on the left and himself on the right. Uncle: "Your right or my right?"

They attack the guards from behind. Uncle cannot handle his man and calls for help. Arthur can step in and save him. If he does, Arthur remarks: "Made a meal outta that, didn't you?" Uncle complains about being left to suffer, then notes that the other pair "ain't as quiet as us". Arthur and Uncle go to help Bill and Charles against the last guards.

The charred wooden frame of a burned-out barn on a grassy slope, with a blue cart and loose planks in front
The same barn after the fire.

Splitting the take

Arthur asks whether they are all still alive. Bill: "Just about..." Arthur tells him he will deal with him later. Uncle points out that they got some money; Arthur answers that they now have Cornwall on their backs again. Uncle: "It was an honest mistake." The four share the take, and Arthur sends everyone off on their own, telling them to stay quiet and keep moving. The mission ends there.

Mission failure

The mission fails if the player:

  • assaults, kills or abandons Bill, Charles or Uncle, or lets one of them be killed;
  • kills either of the wagon drivers;
  • destroys the wagon;
  • fails to escape the burning barn;
  • kills or abandons his horse;
  • dies.

Deaths

  • Cornwall's private guards, killed by Arthur, Uncle, Bill and Charles during the chase, at the barn and in the woods, among them Lowe and Cooperforth, the two men sent to search the barn.
Choices and variants

Who gives the gang away

If the player attacks the guard in the barn before Bill knocks over the bucket, the fight starts at once. Uncle reacts: "Goddamn it, Arthur, what was that?" During the fight Bill throws Arthur's own words back at him: "What happened to 'keep this calm', Arthur?" Arthur answers that the guards were seconds from finding them anyway.

Saving Uncle

In the woods, the guard Uncle attacks overpowers him. Arthur must wait until he has told Uncle to follow his lead, then take down the guard on the right; acting too early means Uncle does not join in. If Arthur does not save him, Uncle scolds him for it. Even if the stealth attack fails, Uncle still remarks that Bill and Charles were less lucky.

Stealing a guard's horse

During the chase, Arthur can take one of the guards' horses; a Seal Brown Dutch Warmblood and a Piebald Tobiano Hungarian Half-bred are among them. The same horses come back at the end of the mission, when the guards attack Bill and Charles: if Arthur kills a rider, takes his horse and stays in the saddle until the mission ends, the horse stays instead of running off.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Save Uncle when he is overpowered.
2Get 20 headshots.
3Complete with at least 80% accuracy.
4Complete the mission without taking any health items.

A scoped rifle such as the Rolling Block Rifle, selected before Arthur leaves his horse at the barn, makes headshots from the barn much easier. Dead Eye helps during the horse chase, and Dead Eye tonics do not break the health items objective.

Quotes
  • You know, Arthur, bitterness, it works on the inside... as well as on your sour face.
    Uncle, when Arthur refuses his tip
  • As long as we get paid or, you get shot... I'm happy.
    Arthur, to Uncle, before setting out
  • You are a sick man, Arthur Morgan... a very sick man indeed.
    Uncle, in reply
  • Looks like Mr. Cornwall's gone and upped his security.
    Arthur, during the barn fight
Trivia
  • The mission takes its name from Uncle's last line. Hosea says the same words in the same chapter, to the Lemoyne Raiders who accuse him and Arthur of stealing their liquor, in Advertising, The New American Art.
  • The barn where the gang hides is the shed of Compson's Stead, an abandoned homestead in Scarlett Meadows. It burns to the ground during the mission and stays a ruin afterwards.
  • A squatter lives in the Compson house during this mission. The two squatters of the house are met again in the stranger mission The Iniquities of History, which starts on a bench outside Rhodes station once this mission is complete.
  • A newspaper article, "Coach Ambushed", reports the robbery of a Cornwall Industries supply coach south of Scarlett Meadows by four thieves, who then burned down a barn during a night gunfight.
  • In an optional conversation on the ride to Valentine in Sodom? Back to Gomorrah, Arthur counts the robbed stagecoach among the gang's offenses against Cornwall, and Bill brushes off the barn fight.
  • If the player does not climb out of the burning barn, Arthur burns to death and the mission fails.
  • If Arthur is seen near the dead guards after the mission, he becomes wanted.
  • The Newsboy Cap can be missed during this mission.
  • In one shot of the cutscene after the wagon is looted, Uncle briefly appears without his beard: he is meant to be wearing his bandana at that moment.