Advertising, The New American Art

Red Dead Redemption 2

Mission 8 of 18

Started by Abigail and Hosea

Clemens Point, Lemoyne

Available after The Course of True Love III, American Distillation and An American Pastoral Scene; can be played in a different order

"Advertising, The New American Art" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2 in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is started by Abigail Marston and led by Hosea Matthews, and it opens once The Course of True Love III, American Distillation and An American Pastoral Scene are complete. It has two parts: a short scene at camp, then the mission itself, at Braithwaite Manor and in Rhodes. This guide lists it eighth of the chapter's 18 missions, which can be played in a different order.

Hosea and Arthur Morgan take the moonshine stolen in American Distillation back to Catherine Braithwaite. She pays them, then sends them to give it away for free in the Grays' saloon in Rhodes. The Lemoyne Raiders, who were going to buy that liquor, break up the party. Back at camp, Dutch and Micah set out their plan to rob both families.

Starting pointMission marker: Abigail
Map of the area around Clemens Point, with the mission's starting point marked Clemens Point
Location
Starts at the Clemens Point camp; the moonshine stash near camp; Braithwaite Manor, Scarlett Meadows; the saloon in Rhodes (Rhodes Parlour House); ends back at camp
Unlocks
Magicians for Sport (after one in-game hour, 300 m away from camp); The Fine Joys of Tobacco; Horse Flesh for Dinner

Started by

Abigail starts the mission at camp; Hosea leads it.

Characters

At camp

Also present: the Braithwaite guards and Catherine's sons, the saloon's drinkers and the Lemoyne Raiders.

Story

Part I: Abigail at camp

When Arthur returns to the Clemens Point camp, Abigail tells him that Hosea and John are looking for him. The two men have gone to the moonshine stash, which Arthur knows. They were planning a visit to the Braithwaite place, but John now has to do something for Dutch, so Hosea wants Arthur to go instead. Arthur asks Abigail what she thinks of the new camp: "Not bad. Nice to be by the water."

Part II: the moonshine stash

Not far from camp, John is helping Hosea load a wagon with the moonshine that Arthur and Dutch took after blowing up the Braithwaites' still in American Distillation. Hosea explains: "Selling it back to where it came from." He has no market for it, and the Braithwaites must have buyers. He adds: "You and Dutch was just doing your duty... when you requisitioned it. Now I'm doing mine."

John leaves. Hosea tells Arthur that, as far as he knows, Dutch has asked John to look into something to do with the Braithwaite horses. On the road, Hosea says it is time for a formal introduction to the family, as Dutch asked: the Braithwaites and the Grays are two old plantation families who hate each other. Arthur mentions the Gray boy and the Braithwaite girl having a secret affair, whom he has been helping in The Course of True Love. He is not sure they are of any use.

Braithwaite Manor

At the gate of Braithwaite Manor, a guard asks what is in the back. Hosea asks for the man of the house; the guard answers: "The 'man' of the house is a lady. Mrs. Catherine Braithwaite." Hosea says he means no harm, and the guards let Arthur drive up to the house.

Hosea tells Catherine that he found something out in the hills. She answers: "I ain't in the market for what's already mine." Hosea asks what she sells the moonshine for; she says a dollar a bottle, and he asks for fifty cents, as a reward for finding it. One of her sons warns that the alternative is getting shot. Catherine laughs and tells her men to pay him.

When Hosea starts to say that they took the liquor on orders, Catherine cuts him off: she knows the orders came from Sheriff Gray. She no longer wants the moonshine. For an extra 10 dollars, she asks them to drive it into Rhodes, to the tavern run by Mr. Gray, and give it out for free. A son protests; she hushes him: "I believe they call that a promotional expense." She invites them to come back and tell her how it went, and maybe play a little cribbage.

Melvin and Fenton

On the road to Rhodes, Hosea says he has finally sold the Cornwall bonds, for close to a thousand dollars: he wanted more, but calls it not bad given how hot the bonds were after the bloodbath in Valentine. He has also heard that Cornwall is paying the Pinkertons to go after gangs like theirs.

Since Arthur and Dutch are already working with the sheriff, Hosea wants a disguise for this job. Arthur refuses to play dress-up. Hosea gives him his role anyway: "I'm the clown... You're the idiot. Just... look... sad and keep quiet. Even you can do that, Arthur." He hands Arthur a hat and a pipe and tells him to push out his lip and squint. Arthur becomes Fenton, the idiot brother; Hosea is Melvin.

Hosea tells Arthur to grab two cases of the moonshine and follow him. Outside the saloon, he introduces the two brothers to the staff: Fenton "turned idiot" and killed their mother, "but it weren't his fault". He presents their trade: "We're in the new trade of advertising which is an American art form about... ensuring people buy the correct things." He hands them a dollar each and then buys half an hour: "One more dollar says give us half an hour, what harm can we do in half an hour?"

Front of a two-storey white wooden building with green trim, a balcony and a sign reading Rhodes Parlour House, a man sitting on the porch and a horse on the right
The Rhodes Parlour House, the saloon in Rhodes where Melvin and Fenton give the moonshine away.

Free drinks in Rhodes

Inside, Hosea announces that for the next thirty minutes every drink in the bar is free, and that the only rule is to drink them. Arthur goes behind the bar and pours shot after shot. The drinkers call for Fenton from every corner. One of them remarks: "Mr. Gray won't be happy about this." The free drinks go on into the night.

Armed men walk in; a drinker recognizes them: "It's the Lemoyne Raiders." One of them accuses Hosea: "You're the bastards who stole the liquor we was going to buy." Hosea tries again ("Gentlemen, we're in advertising... come on in, have a drink."), then, when told it is their liquor, answers: "An honest mistake." The same Raider orders his men to attack.

Escape from the saloon

Arthur fights the Raiders inside the saloon. Hosea leads the way upstairs, and Arthur jumps from there into the moonshine wagon below. Ammunition is unlimited during the escape. Hosea drives out of Rhodes while Arthur shoots the Raiders who chase them, from an alley behind them and from the road ahead; a train comes into view during the chase.

Once they are safe, Arthur says: "Jesus, all this over a few bottles of booze." Hosea thinks the Raiders mostly do not want another gang on their patch. Arthur asks whether "that woman" set them up; Hosea does not think so, but is not sure. Arthur says he keeps running into those men; Hosea calls them a local militia, unhappy about the new competition.

Hosea decides to go back to Braithwaite Manor and give Catherine some of the remaining moonshine as a peace offering. The gang's chest is slowly filling up again, he says; part of him would rather they got themselves lost, but they still need much more money first. Arthur goes back to camp to talk to Dutch.

Dutch's plan

At camp, Dutch describes the two families, with Micah at his side. On one side are the Grays: "Scots... degenerates... drunkards... the local law. You couldn't make this stuff up. Rich as Croesus." On the other, their mortal enemies, the Braithwaites, moonshiners. Arthur adds the young lovers: "some... inbred retelling of Romeo and Juliet". Asked what they have in mind, Micah answers: "We try to rob 'em both."

Arthur objects that they have lawmen in three different states after them. Dutch answers that they need money and that the two families will kill each other anyway, with or without the gang. He tells Arthur that Sheriff Gray put in a word with his father, which is how the gang got in at the Grays' place. The plan: convince each family that the gang is on its side, rob both, and be gone before they realize who did it.

Dutch calls it "payback for my daddy"; his father died fighting the South in the Civil War, as he tells Arthur in The New South. Arthur answers: "Payback? I ain't in the revenge business, Dutch. Least of all for something that happened a long time ago." Dutch then leaves him to write a letter.

Choices and variants

Arthur's next move

Dutch has sent Sean to Braithwaite Manor as well. Arthur can join Hosea and Sean there, which leads to The Fine Joys of Tobacco and the Grays' tobacco fields, or join John and Javier at Caliga Hall, the Grays' estate, about the Braithwaites' prized horses, which leads to Horse Flesh for Dinner. Both missions open at the end of this one, along with Magicians for Sport.

Variants

  • Part I can be skipped by going straight to Hosea and John at the moonshine stash.
  • If Preaching Forgiveness as He Went has been completed before this mission, Arthur calls the Raiders "the bastards from Shady Belle" at the start of the gunfight.
  • If a witness runs off, Hosea tells Arthur to stop him before he reports them to the law.
  • Killing horses during this mission costs no honor, as in Urban Pleasures, The Fine Art of Conversation and Our Best Selves.

Mission failure

The mission fails if Arthur attacks, kills or abandons Hosea, lets him die, attacks or kills John or any of the Braithwaite guards, leaves Braithwaite Manor, alerts the law, destroys or disables the moonshine wagon, or dies.

Gold Medal objectives
Objectives to complete for the Gold Medal.
#Objective
1Get 5 headshots on Lemoyne Raiders in the saloon.
2Complete with at least 90% accuracy.
3Complete the mission without taking any health items.

The Raiders who threaten Hosea when the cutscene ends and the three who appear upstairs across the bar are the best targets for the headshots. Any tonic such as Snake Oil has to be taken before getting on the wagon, as it cannot be used during the chase. The accuracy requirement is strict: each shot counts.

Quotes
  • Modest little homestead, isn't it?
    Hosea, arriving at Braithwaite Manor
  • Now, who wants to get shot over a bottle or two of liquor?
    Hosea, to the Braithwaites
  • The wife's gonna kill me. I only went out for milk.
    A drinker in the Rhodes saloon
  • Good evening, gentlemen. Quiet libation?
    Hosea, as the Lemoyne Raiders walk in
  • Remind me never to take up a career in... what was it?
    Arthur after the escape; Hosea answers: "Advertising."
  • That was fun, Fenton. We'll make an actor of you yet.
    Hosea, before going back to Braithwaite Manor
Trivia
  • Arthur and Hosea were first meant to wear costumes for Melvin and Fenton: blue patched overalls, long false beards and wide-brimmed hats. The outfits were cut from the final game but remain in its files.
  • A cut Rhodes doctor and a fiddle player were also meant to be seen drunk in the saloon during the mission.
  • After the mission, people in the Rhodes saloon may recognize Arthur as "Fenton".
  • The train car seen near the start of the mission is a sleeper car with beds, one of the few times it appears in the game; it carries no passengers here.
  • During the saloon shootout, one Lemoyne Raider wears a full yellow mask; his appearance is drawn at random from 33 masked models each time the mission is reloaded.
  • The subtitles of part I contain a typo: "lookng" for "looking".