Sodom? Back to Gomorrah
Red Dead Redemption 2
Mission 10 of 18
Available one in-game hour after Preaching Forgiveness as He Went, once American Distillation is complete; can be played in a different order
"Sodom? Back to Gomorrah" is a story mission of Red Dead Redemption 2, in Chapter 3: Clemens Point. It is given by Bill Williamson at the Clemens Point camp and takes place in Valentine, in the Heartlands of New Hanover, and at Downes Ranch. It becomes available one in-game hour after Preaching Forgiveness as He Went, once American Distillation is complete. This guide lists it 10th of the chapter's 18 missions; the chapter can be played in a different order.
Bill and Karen Jones have been planning to rob the Valentine bank since Horseshoe Overlook. With Lenny Summers and Arthur Morgan, they go back to the town the gang left in a shootout. Karen distracts the staff, Arthur opens the safes, and the four escape the law. Arthur then rides to Downes Ranch to collect a debt from Thomas Downes's widow.

- Location
- Starts and ends at the Clemens Point camp; Valentine Savings Bank, Valentine, The Heartlands, New Hanover; Downes Ranch, The Heartlands
- Rewards
- A share of the bank money; the Downes debt, collected for Strauss; a small honor gain if the safes are cracked without alerting the law
- Unlocks
- Blessed are the Peacemakers, once Magicians for Sport is also complete
Story
Bill's unfinished business
At Clemens Point, Bill calls Arthur over: they have something cooking. The job has been in preparation since Horseshoe, Bill says, until Arthur kicked up all that commotion in Valentine, in The Sheep and the Goats. To Bill, the Valentine bank is unfinished business. Arthur answers that it was not his fault: "It was just one of them things."
Bill asks why he is called a fool and an idiot every time he gets into trouble, while Arthur's trouble is just "one of them things". Lenny and Karen agree that it is a good point. Karen asks Arthur to hit the bank with them. Four of them can take it easily, she says, but there will be law if they linger, local men rounded up and pressed into action. Arthur asks whether it is worth the risk. Karen: "It's a bank, Arthur."
Karen adds that, according to a man she met, the take should be good: it is the end of the stock sales, with plenty of money and plenty of people around. Arthur agrees to take a look. Karen goes to change out of what she calls her rags, since she will be performing. Bill assures Arthur that they put a lot of research into this one.
Strauss and the Downes debt
Before they leave, Strauss tells Arthur that the debtor Thomas Downes is apparently dead. Arthur answers that Downes did not seem very well. Strauss says the man has a wife and child, that his wife will assume the debt, and asks Arthur to go up there and collect when he can: they lent the Downes family a lot of money. Arthur had come to collect from Thomas Downes in Money Lending and Other Sins III.
Karen returns: "Gentlemen... let's go rob ourselves a bank." Bill explains the plan: Karen goes in first as a distraction, then the men rush in. It is a small bank in a little town, without much security, and Arthur comes along as "a... insurance policy".
The ride to Valentine
On the way, Bill says they will see how it looks. If they can get in, Miss Jones goes ahead, since nobody in Valentine will recognize her. Karen hesitates between two routines: men always like "the lost little girl", but nobody plays the drunken harlot quite like her. She scouted the place a few days earlier and saw only a couple of guards. Bill offers to handle the vault, and Arthur keeps the job for himself.
Bill then asks whether Dutch told Arthur about the deals he has been cooking up with the Gray boys. He has been drinking with them a couple of times, and they seem to be looking for extra security; there could be something in it for the gang. Arthur tells him to be smart about it, since they have a lot of irons in that fire. The Grays later speak to Bill about a security job; the meeting in Rhodes turns into the ambush of A Short Walk in a Pretty Town.
In Valentine, they leave the horses off the main street. Arthur tells Karen to go to work, and Karen asks which act he wants.
Inside the Valentine Savings Bank
Karen enters the bank and plays her part until the staff are off their guard; when Bill wants to go in, Arthur tells him to wait until she has them reeled in. Then Karen draws: "Get your goddamn hands up! This is a goddamn robbery!" Arthur, Bill and Lenny burst in. Lenny gives Karen the key, and she unlocks the door behind the counter.
Arthur takes the teller to the vault and forces him to open it, shouting that he is too slow. Inside, Bill orders the teller to open the lock boxes, but the man says that only the manager can. Arthur decides to crack the safes or blow them up, and asks the others to keep watch.
While Arthur works, Lenny threatens to shoot a hostage in the leg if he moves it again, and a customer begs to be let go. Karen and Lenny can hear people outside. Bill keeps asking how long it will take. Asked whether they have enough, Arthur answers: "Maybe. It's never enough."
Getting out of Valentine
If the safes were cracked quickly, the robbers walk out quietly, Karen leading the way, and Arthur tells the hostages to count to a hundred and keep their mouths shut. The alarm is raised as they leave, and they shoot their way to the horses. If the safes were blown, lawmen have already surrounded the bank (see Choices and variants).
The four ride out of Valentine with lawmen on their tail. Bill shouts: "Gotta beat that train, Morgan!" They cross the tracks just ahead of a passing train, which cuts off their pursuers. Arthur thinks they have lost them.
Karen thanks them. Arthur calls the job "Stupid and dangerous... thank you, Bill." Bill answers that they are alive and paid, and sees no problem. Arthur: "And that is the problem." He admits that it is a very good take, and that Dutch will be happy, even if it came with a heap of trouble. Karen found it fun. Arthur sends the others away, tells them not to head straight back to camp and to make sure they are not followed, and leaves for other business: Mrs. Downes.
Downes Ranch
At Downes Ranch, Edith Downes tells Arthur that her husband is not cold in the ground and that he has come back, when she had nearly paid off what was owed. Arthur answers that her husband knew the rules when he took the money, that he is sorry about the way things turned out, but that Thomas had a choice.
Edith: "He didn't have a choice. He was good, and he did good. There wasn't no choice in that. And you've as good as killed him yourself... and don't kid yourself. You had a choice." Arthur replies that she speaks as if killing mattered to him. Edith asks whether he ever wonders about eternity: "You should." Arthur says he hopes it is hot and terrible, otherwise he will feel he has been sold a false bill of goods, and asks her to fetch the money.
Arthur then asks Edith's son, Archie, whether he has a lazy eye or a lack of respect. Edith goes into the house. Archie answers that he has no lazy eye, nor respect for the likes of Arthur. Arthur: "Well, maybe when your mother's finished mourning your father... I'll keep her in black... on your behalf. You think on that, boy." Archie says that maybe other events will transpire. Arthur tells him to stick to his books: "vengeance is an idiot's game."
Edith comes back with the money. Arthur thanks her for her punctuality, which he says is next to godliness. Edith corrects him: "That's cleanliness." Arthur says he will take her word for it, wishes her good day and rides back to camp. The mission ends there.
Mission failure
The mission fails if the player:
- assaults, kills or abandons Bill, Karen or Lenny, or lets one of them be killed;
- alerts the law too early;
- shoots any of the people in the bank, or kills the teller before he opens the vault;
- abandons Valentine, or returns to Valentine on the ride to Downes Ranch;
- kills or abandons his horse;
- dies.
Deaths
- Valentine lawmen, killed by Arthur, Bill, Lenny and Karen during the escape.
- Thomas Downes, who dies before the mission; Strauss gives Arthur the news.
Choices and variants
Lost girl or drunken harlot
The player picks Karen's routine. With the lost girl, Karen asks Arthur whether even he longs to save fallen women, then goes in crying that she is ruined, that "He said he loved me!", that he promised to make a lady of her, and that she is with child and does not want to go back to the workhouse.
With the harlot, Karen calls the men a bunch of filthy sinners and heartbreakers and goes in looking for "him". A man in the bank calls her a disgrace to her sex. She claims he was not so stuck up the night before, and he insists he has never seen her in his life.
Cracking or blowing the safes
Cracking the safes is slower but quieter, as Arthur says. If the player is quick, the gang leaves the bank before the law arrives, and the lawmen only start the pursuit when the robbers have almost reached their horses. If the cracking takes too long, the law surrounds the bank, as with dynamite. Cracking every safe without alerting the law and without shooting anyone in the bank gives a small honor gain.
With dynamite, Bill warns that the law will be all over them. Karen spots "company" outside. A lawman calls on the robbers to come out. Karen offers to go first. Arthur asks whether she is insane. Karen: "Probably." She walks out with her hands up, says she made a terrible mistake, then draws and opens fire, and the three men join her. The gang must fight its way to the horses.
Conversations on the ride
On the ride to Valentine, the player can start several conversations:
- Back to Valentine: Bill says it is downright pathetic to work a town and not hit the bank. Arthur answers that they went beyond working it and shot the place to hell; Bill says Arthur did, while he played it cool. He adds that nobody lets him forget the dynamite on Cornwall's train.
- Cornwall: Arthur sums up the gang's record against Cornwall (his train robbed, a heap of his men shot in Valentine, his stagecoach robbed in An Honest Mistake) and wonders why they are going back to the one place Cornwall knew to find them. Bill: "Forget about Cornwall... he can't have many men left at this point."
- Karen is glad to have Arthur along, but doubts Lenny can keep his head after his night out with Arthur in A Quiet Time. She calls Arthur a bad drunk and admits that it takes one to know one.
- Lenny explains that he first thought the job a bad idea, then figured every idea looks bad if you think about it long enough, and that he told the others they needed Arthur. If Preaching Forgiveness as He Went has been played, Arthur also congratulates him on the Shady Belle job; Lenny says the Raiders would have loved to string him up, and Arthur answers: "You'll outlive the lot of us."
- Arthur and Lenny agree to skip the saloon this time. Lenny says that next time he will know what Arthur means by "a couple of drinks".
- Karen asks about the Grays and the Braithwaites. Arthur explains that Dutch and Hosea want to get in the middle of an old feud and get some gold out of it, and that Dutch has already got them deputized.
In an optional exchange during the mission, Arthur also brings up a bank he robbed in Tucson, Arizona, in the mid-1890s with Javier Escuella and Karen, who walked in disguised as a nun with two pistols hidden under her clothes.
Gold Medal objectives
| # | Objective |
|---|---|
| 1 | Loot all the safes. |
| 2 | Headshot 5 mounted lawmen during the horseback escape. |
| 3 | Get to Downes Ranch within 1 minute and 55 seconds. |
| 4 | Complete with at least 70% accuracy. |
| 5 | Complete the mission without taking any health items. |
Cracking the safes is slower, but leaves fewer lawmen to fight, and all the safes can still be looted if the player is quick. On a controller, vibration helps: turn the stick slowly until Arthur raises a finger. With dynamite, a stick on every safe and a single fuse blows them all open at once; blowing them one at a time leaves too little time to loot them all.
Quotes
Oh, it can go wrong. Anything can, once the shooting starts.
Bill, when Arthur asks about his "can't go wrong" planDon't count your chickens just yet.
Arthur, in the vaultWe're shooting our way out of here, boys!
Karen, if the safes were blown
Trivia
- The title refers to Sodom and Gomorrah, the two cities destroyed in the Book of Genesis. The gang is going back to Valentine, which it left after the shootout of The Sheep and the Goats.
- Arthur remembers lines from the Downes Ranch scene later in the game, depending on his honor. In A Fork in the Road, he hears Edith's line about her husband being a good man with high honor, or her line that Arthur as good as killed him with low honor. With low honor, his own reply about killing comes back on his last ride, in Red Dead Redemption.
- If Edith Downes has already come to camp to announce her husband's death, Arthur still reacts to Strauss's news as if he did not know.
- Valentine's sheriff, Curtis Malloy, does not take part in the robbery, but he can be seen in his office when the gang arrives in town.
- The bank has two lawmen on guard instead of the usual one, both in outfits not seen before the mission. It is also the only time the owner of the Saints Hotel and the doctor Ben Calloway can be seen in the bank.
- A pink jewelry box sits on a desk before the vault. Shooting it lets Arthur pick it up, but always alerts the law and cancels the honor gain.
- After the mission, the owner of the Wallace Station general store tells Arthur that he is glad he does not keep his money in Valentine, because some gang cleared that bank out.




